Skip To Content

Four consultations a week. Book It

Guides · What Advice Costs

What Is A Fee-For-Service Financial Adviser?

A fee-for-service financial adviser charges you directly for their advice, rather than being paid by a product company. That sounds clean. The catch is that the label covers very different things: a fixed fee for a written plan, an hourly rate, or a percentage of your balance every year. Only the first two stop when the work stops.

What Does Fee-For-Service Actually Mean?

Put simply, you pay the adviser, not a product provider. In Australia advisers can't take commissions on super or investments, so most advisers now describe themselves as fee-for-service.

That's the problem with the label. It says who pays. It doesn't say how much, or for how long.

Moneysmart lists four ways advisers charge:

Fee type How it works
Fixed fee A set price for a defined job, such as a Statement of Advice (SOA)
Hourly rate A set price per hour, often for one-off questions
Percentage of your balance A yearly fee based on the size of your portfolio
Ongoing fee A regular fee, often monthly, for reviews, calls and reports

All four are "fee-for-service". Over ten years, they are very different products.

Is Fee-For-Service The Same As Commission-Free?

Not quite. Advisers can't receive commissions on super or investments, but they can on some insurance policies. Moneysmart says you have to consent to those, and the consent generally carries over to renewals.

So an adviser can be fee-for-service and still earn a commission on your life insurance. It's worth knowing before you say yes.

Now the bigger point, which is in the book. The industry bristles at the word commission. But what is a commission? It's a percentage cut to the salesperson for selling a product. If an adviser recommends an investment platform, they pay themselves 1% of your balance. If they don't, they get $0. It isn't called a commission. It's called an "ongoing service fee".

The difference is who pays. A commission is paid by the company that makes the product. An ongoing service fee comes straight out of your account, every month, while your adviser is sleeping.

How Much Does A Fee-For-Service Adviser Cost On $500,000 And $1 Million?

This is where the label stops mattering and the dollars start. Here's what a 1% yearly fee, a common industry norm, comes to in dollars.

Balance Fee at 1% a year Per week Over 10 years, balance flat Over 20 years, balance flat
$500,000 $5,000 about $96 $50,000 $100,000
$1,000,000 $10,000 about $192 $100,000 $200,000

"It's only 1%" is much easier to sell than "you want $10,000 a year!?" And if the portfolio goes up, the fee goes up. It's no extra work, but the bill rises. Grow that balance 5% a year (an illustration, not a prediction) and the 20-year total on $1 million is about $330,000.

Imagine your accountant said, I'll do your tax return, but my fee is 10% of your yearly income. Or an estate planning lawyer wanted 5% of your estate. You'd walk out.

As one industry critic put it, if you have a million dollars, you walk into your annual review carrying a $10,000 briefcase. Most people don't pay their doctor or accountant that much.

What Does Fee-For-Service Look Like As A Flat One-Off Fee?

This is how I work, as one example of the model. I charge for the time taken, the same way you'd pay a doctor, a lawyer or a plumber.

  • Initial Consultation: $330. If you go ahead, it's credited against the advice fee.
  • Statement of Advice: from $6,600 including GST.
  • Ongoing fees: none. Commissions: none.

Advice about your super can sometimes be paid from your super, at extra cost.

The fee stays the same whether your balance is $400,000 or $1.4 million. Which is the point. Two pieces of advice that take the same work cost the same, and nothing is deducted from your account afterwards.

Here's how it compares, using round numbers.

Worked Example 1: A Couple With $500,000

Say a couple at 60 pay an ongoing fee of 1% on $500,000, and keep paying for 20 years. Balance flat for simplicity.

Ongoing 1% fee One-off advice, twice
Cost each time $5,000 a year $6,600 each time (my starting fee)
How many times 20 2
Total $100,000 $13,200

The ongoing adviser would need to add about $87,000 of value beyond the one-off plan to break even. That's before counting what those fees would have earned if they'd stayed in the super fund.

Worked Example 2: A Couple With $1 Million

Same couple, same 20 years, now with $1 million.

Ongoing 1% fee One-off advice, twice
Cost each time $10,000 a year $6,600 each time
Total over 20 years $200,000 $13,200

Notice the one-off cost doesn't move. The ongoing fee doubled because the balance did. The work didn't.

What Does An Ongoing Fee Actually Buy?

To be fair, your adviser usually does some good work at the start: education, contribution advice, getting insurance sorted. Then, in many cases, they sit there doing not a lot.

The usual defence is that your life changes, so the advice needs monitoring. I don't think I've ever seen a financial planner who didn't recommend more financial planning. But what does your life changing have to do with your super? If you lose your job tomorrow, would your super change? No. Most "further advice" is putting more money into the same fund, like an inheritance.

Another defence is that ongoing fees are an "alignment of interests". Sure, in the same way KFC aligns the interests of chickens with Colonel Sanders.

By law you have to opt in each year to ongoing fees, and the adviser must give you written details of the services you'll get. That's the document to read. It's a useful test: what exactly was delivered last year?

How Often Do You Actually Need Financial Advice?

The majority of us need advice twice in our lives. Once to get set up, typically in the lead up to having a family, or in your 30s and 40s. Then once at retirement.

You know who else solves problems quickly for customers? Pharmacists. Architects. Physiotherapists. Plumbers. None of them send you a bill every year for the tap they fixed in 2019.

That's a general view of mine, not a rule. Some people with complicated situations genuinely want regular input, and paying for that is a fair choice. It depends on what you're actually getting, and what it costs in dollars.

What Questions Can I Ask A Fee-For-Service Adviser?

These are the questions I'd want answered before paying anyone, including me:

  1. Is this a fixed fee, an hourly rate, a percentage or an ongoing fee? Ask for the yearly cost in dollars, not percentages.
  2. Do you receive commissions on anything you recommend, including insurance?
  3. What exactly do I get for the fee, and what would cost extra?
  4. Do you own, or get paid by, any product you might recommend?
  5. Can I see your registration? Every adviser is listed on ASIC's Financial Advisers Register on Moneysmart.

If the answers come back fuzzy, that's an answer.

What Does Good Fee-For-Service Advice Look Like?

No industry is 100% bad apples, and there are good financial advisers. They're rare, but they exist. Good advice might save you a truckload of tax, set up the right insurance, or simply let you feel at ease about retirement. That last one is worth more than people expect.

Here's what I look for:

  1. Your super sits in a low-cost industry fund (with very rare exceptions).
  2. Insurance through super (group insurance) is considered first, because it's usually cheaper.
  3. There are no ongoing fees.
  4. You pay for the time taken.

I'm also wary of the word "holistic". It may be the most abused word in financial services. If an adviser calls themselves your personal CFO or wealth partner for life's ups and downs, my first question is what it costs.

What Does One-Off Advice Work Out That The Rules Don't?

Knowing how advisers charge doesn't tell you what the right decision is. The rules can't tell you which fund and investment option suit your situation, how much insurance is worth holding, how contributions and a pension are set up, or how all of it fits with the Age Pension.

That's the work. A written Statement of Advice puts real numbers to those decisions for your situation, and you pay once. If you want to read how I price it, the full cost breakdown is on the site.

Next Step

See how I help with financial advice costs, or book a consultation.

General advice warning: this article is general advice only and reflects my professional opinion. It has been prepared without taking into account your objectives, financial situation or needs.

Book A Consultation

If you do not need advice, you find out for $330, not $6,600.

  • 45 minutes with the adviser himself, not a junior
  • A fixed quote on the call, if advice is warranted
  • The $330 is credited in full if you proceed

Why $330 and not free? A free first meeting is usually paid for later, through ongoing fees. I would rather you paid once for my time and owed me nothing.

Book A $330 Consultation

Pay $330 now. A consultation, not an advice session. Reschedule up to 48 hours before.