Skip To Content

Four consultations a week. Book It

Guides · Retirement Advice

How Do I Choose The Best Super Fund For Retirement?

The best super fund for retirement is the one that keeps the most of its return for you. In my view, that comes down to long-term net returns in the pension (retirement phase) balanced option, total fees in dollars, a standalone cash option and decent service. Australia has close to a dozen absolutely wonderful world class operators that tick those boxes.

There is no official ranking of pension funds, so here's how I'd judge one, without the sales pitch.

What Is The Best Super Fund For Retirees?

Put simply, there isn't one winner. There's a short list of very good funds and a long list of expensive ones.

The investment gods decide the returns. Neither you nor anyone else can magically manufacture them. What you decide is how much of that return you keep, by picking a good fund and choosing the right option.

In Australia, at retirement, you become your own employer, investment manager and financial adviser. That sounds intimidating, but you don't need to become a finance guru. You've got close to a dozen absolutely wonderful world class operators who will do literally everything for you. In a sense, you pay your super fund to stress for you.

So the real question isn't "which fund is best?" It's "how do I tell a good one from an average one?" Here are the things I look at.

Which Super Fund Has The Best Returns Over 10 Years?

Returns are the headline, but only if you compare the right numbers. Four things matter:

  1. Net of fees. A return before fees is a brochure number. The one that lands in your account is after fees.
  2. The pension version, not the accumulation version. In retirement phase the fund pays no tax on earnings, so pension returns are usually higher than the same option in accumulation. Compare pension with pension.
  3. The same kind of option. A balanced option against a balanced option. Option names aren't standardised, so a "balanced" option at one fund can hold more shares than "growth" at another.
  4. Ten years, not one. Any fund can have a great year. Ten years shows you who does it consistently, across good markets and bad ones.

Ratings firms and comparison sites publish ten year pension tables. They're useful, but they are businesses, and some are paid by the funds they rate. In my view, a top-10 list is a starting point, not a verdict.

Also remember, profits don't happen in a straight line. That neat 7% a year your fund reports is not 7% every year.

Are Industry Super Funds Better Than Retail Funds?

In my view, generally, yes.

Industry funds, and other profit-to-member funds, are run for their members. There are no shareholders taking a cut. Retail funds and wrap products are run by companies that need to make a profit from your balance, and many come with an adviser taking an ongoing percentage on top.

That's why I think low-cost industry funds generally beat retail and wrap products over the long run. It isn't magic. It's primary school maths. Lower costs leave more of the same market return in your account.

Scale helps too. A big industry fund can negotiate lower fees and get access to investments, like unlisted infrastructure and property, that a small fund or an individual can't.

Here's the fair caveat. Not every industry fund is good, and not every retail fund is bad. Size and the label don't replace checking the numbers.

How Much Do Fees Really Cost In Retirement?

More than they look. A fee written as a percentage sounds small. Written in dollars, it doesn't.

Worked Example 1: $500,000 In An Account-Based Pension

Two retirees each start an account-based pension with $500,000. Both earn the same 6% a year before fees and both draw $30,000 a year. The only difference is fees: one pays 0.6% a year in total, the other 1.6%.

After 10 years Fees of 0.6% a year Fees of 1.6% a year
Fees paid in year one about $3,000 about $8,000
Total fees over 10 years about $29,000 about $73,500
Balance left after 10 years about $461,500 about $402,000
Difference in balance about $59,400 less

That's roughly $59,000 gone for the same market, the same spending and the same retiree. The extra fees alone were about $44,000, and the rest is the return those dollars would have earned. It's the cost of a very nice car, or several years of overseas trips.

Worked Example 2: The Same Fees At Different Balances

Funds quote fees as a percentage. Your bank statement shows dollars. Here's what each looks like a year:

Balance 0.6% a year 1.6% a year Extra cost a year
$200,000 $1,200 $3,200 $2,000
$500,000 $3,000 $8,000 $5,000
$800,000 $4,800 $12,800 $8,000

At $800,000, the gap is about $150 a week. Every week, for the rest of your retirement, whether markets go up or down.

When I compare funds, I look at total fees in dollars at the actual balance, not the percentage on the brochure. That means administration fees, investment fees and any adviser fee taken from the account, all added together.

What Else Matters In A Pension Account?

Returns and fees do most of the work. A few other things separate a good retirement fund from an average one.

A standalone cash option. A balanced option holds some cash, but I like a fund with a separate cash option too. When (not if) markets deliver a stinker, money in cash cannot go down. Because industry funds don't take a big cut off the interest, the cash returns they provide are generally good.

A sensible range of options. Balanced, cash, and a handful of others is plenty. Hundreds of choices mostly create confusion and fees.

Switching between options. Some funds will rebalance between your cash and balanced options automatically if you ask. Switching options is usually free and, inside super, there's no tax on the switch.

Insurance. In accumulation, insurance can matter a lot. In the pension phase it often doesn't, because most pension accounts carry no insurance. It's rarely a reason to choose a fund for retirement.

Service and retirement tools. How easy is it to change your payment, take a lump sum or get a Centrelink income stream schedule? With a good industry fund, that schedule takes two minutes online or over the phone. Good funds also run retirement seminars, calculators and general advice for members.

Can I Use The YourSuper Comparison Tool For Retirement?

Partly. The ATO's YourSuper comparison tool ranks MySuper products by net returns, updated quarterly, and shows the result of APRA's annual performance test. A product that misses the benchmark is marked "underperforming".

The catch: MySuper products are accumulation accounts. The tool doesn't rank retirement phase pension products. So it tells you how a fund's default accumulation option has performed, not its pension option.

It's still useful. A fund whose MySuper product has failed the performance test is a red flag, and a fund that sits near the top of the table on net returns is usually a decent sign for its pension option too. Moneysmart's own advice is to compare like with like over at least five years, and not to choose a fund on a website rating alone.

Is It Hard To Switch Super Funds In Retirement?

No. Switching funds generally costs nothing. Exit fees on super were banned from 1 July 2019, and moving between funds in the pension phase doesn't trigger tax.

There are a few things to check first, which is fair to say:

  1. Time out of the market. Money in transit for a week or two misses whatever markets do in that time.
  2. An older pension. An account-based pension started before 1 January 2015 may have older, kinder rules for the Age Pension income test and the Commonwealth Seniors Health Card. Starting a new one loses them.
  3. The paperwork. You'll need a new Centrelink income stream schedule, and you'll need to redo your beneficiary nominations.

Remember, though: you can change your investment option whenever you like, usually with zero costs and zero taxes. In my view, staying put in an expensive fund because switching feels like hard work is the costly option.

What Does Advice Add When Choosing A Fund?

A list of criteria gets you most of the way. What it can't do is weigh them for your situation: which option fits how you'll spend, how much sits in cash, whether an old pension is worth keeping, how two partners' accounts work together, and what the Age Pension will do as your balance changes.

As part of my advice, I recommend which fund and which option, and explain why. It's one-off advice for a fixed fee: no commissions, no ongoing fees. Advice about your super can sometimes be paid from your super, at extra cost.

Next Step

See how I help with retirement advice, or book a consultation.

General advice warning: this article is general advice only and reflects my professional opinion. It has been prepared without taking into account your objectives, financial situation or needs.

Book A Consultation

If you do not need advice, you find out for $330, not $6,600.

  • 45 minutes with the adviser himself, not a junior
  • A fixed quote on the call, if advice is warranted
  • The $330 is credited in full if you proceed

Why $330 and not free? A free first meeting is usually paid for later, through ongoing fees. I would rather you paid once for my time and owed me nothing.

Book A $330 Consultation

Pay $330 now. A consultation, not an advice session. Reschedule up to 48 hours before.