Skip To Content

Four consultations a week. Book It

Guides · Retirement Advice

Should I Buy An Annuity?

It depends on how much you value a guaranteed income over control of your money. An annuity swaps a lump sum for a regular income, often for life, and once you're in, you generally can't get out. Personally, on today's offerings, I wouldn't touch one. For a very small number of people, mostly older retirees, I can see the appeal.

Here's how they work, how Centrelink treats them, and what you give up.

What Is An Annuity?

Put simply, an annuity is where a company takes your money, say $200,000, and promises you a set income in return. Think of it like a term deposit, but on steroids.

The company invests your money and tries to earn more than it's paying you. It keeps the excess. You get peace of mind. If it earns less, in theory, it wears the loss.

Annuities are sometimes sold as a "lifetime income stream" or similar. Same thing.

What Is The Difference Between A Lifetime And Fixed Term Annuity?

There are two broad types:

Fixed term annuity Lifetime annuity
How long it pays A set number of years For the rest of your life
What's left when it ends Possibly a residual amount you chose Nothing, unless you chose a reversionary or guaranteed option
Can you get your money out? Generally no, or only with penalties Generally no, or only with penalties

Payments can be a fixed amount, rise by a set percentage, rise with inflation, or move with an investment option. If you die, payments usually stop, unless you nominated a reversionary beneficiary, often your spouse at a reduced rate, or picked a guaranteed period.

The life part is no joke. Once the cooling-off period ends, you generally can't change the terms or take a lump sum out. Some products allow limited withdrawals in the early years, often with a withdrawal value that shrinks over time and then disappears.

How Much Does A $200,000 Annuity Pay?

It depends on your age, interest rates and which options you choose. The more protection you want (inflation, a death benefit), the lower the payment.

Worked Example 1: $200,000 At 67

As an indicative rate only, based on one provider's published rates from mid-2025 (the latest I could access), a lifetime annuity bought at 67 with full inflation protection pays somewhere around $5,400 a year for every $100,000. Rates change regularly, so treat this as a ballpark, not a quote.

Step Amount
Purchase price $200,000
Indicative payment, about $5,400 per $100,000 about $10,800 a year
Per fortnight about $415

That's paid for life and rises with inflation. In exchange, the $200,000 is no longer yours. It doesn't go to your estate (unless you've bought a death benefit), you can't dip into it for a new roof, and you can't move it if you're unhappy.

How Does Centrelink Treat A Lifetime Annuity?

Lifetime income streams bought from 1 July 2019 get special treatment under the Age Pension means test:

  1. Assets test: 60% of the purchase price counts as an asset until age 84 (or for at least five years if you buy later in life). After that, 30% counts, for life.
  2. Income test: 60% of the payments count as income.

Compare that to an account-based pension, where 100% of the balance counts under the assets test and the whole balance is deemed to earn income under the income test.

So a lifetime annuity is assessed more gently than the same money left in super. That's why it's often pitched as a way to get more Age Pension.

Does An Annuity Increase Your Age Pension?

Often, yes, at least in the first years. Here's a single homeowner aged 67, comparing the two.

Worked Example 2: $600,000 Account-Based Pension Versus $400,000 Plus A $200,000 Annuity

Assume no other assessable assets, and the indicative annuity payment from example 1.

A: $600,000 account-based pension B: $400,000 account-based + $200,000 annuity
Assets Centrelink counts $600,000 $520,000 ($400,000 + 60% of $200,000)
Pension under assets test, per fortnight about $437 about $677
Income Centrelink counts, per fortnight about $814 (deemed) about $775 (deemed + 60% of payments)
Pension under income test, per fortnight about $944 about $963
Age Pension paid (the lower test) about $437 a fortnight about $677 a fortnight

In this case, the annuity lifts the Age Pension by about $240 a fortnight, or roughly $6,240 a year. From 84, only 30% of the annuity counts, so the gap widens further.

That's the honest result, and it's not trivial. The trade-off is that $200,000 has left your hands for good. In option A, if you die at 75, what's left goes to your family. In option B, a good chunk of the $200,000 likely stays in the pot.

The result also changes with your numbers. Someone already on the full pension gets no assets test benefit at all. A couple, a renter or someone with more assets will get a different answer.

What Is The Downside Of An Annuity?

Your super is your wage. But no one goes on the nightly news to tell you your pay cheque was down 5% because of some avoidable crisis. With super, they do. That's stressful, and I get it.

I think of market ups and downs for retirees like sunburn. Irritating and uncomfortable. Then along come annuities claiming they can sell you sunscreen that stops you getting sunburnt.

Sounds good, but this sunscreen has side effects. Imagine it prevented sunburn, but also attracted snakes, sharks, telemarketers, parking inspectors and your most annoying in-law, and made you stink. Would you take that trade? Personally, I'd rather invest in a good hat.

The price isn't just a chunk of your returns. It's:

  • Control and flexibility. Once in, you generally can't get out.
  • Accountability. If the company turns out to be no good, you can't move. There's no portability, no vote, no rights.
  • Your estate. Most of the time, if you die, the money stays in the pool and keeps paying everyone else. Many offer a reversionary option for your spouse at a reduced rate.

We're living in a period of radical change. In my view, the worst thing you can do in that environment is lock yourself in for life.

What Does "Guaranteed" Actually Mean?

Annuities are funded two ways. First, the provider invests your money. Second, pooling: when someone dies early, their money stays in the pot and pays those who live longer.

If a company promises 6% a year and can only earn 3%, eventually something gives. No one controls the market.

And what if the pool is full of uncommonly healthy people? I'd happily buy an annuity from a provider whose customers were strictly base jumpers and two-pack-a-day smokers, but annuities don't screen anything except your age. People are living longer.

A guarantee that comes with a 90-page document in legalese is not as guaranteed as you think. Insurance companies showed in the GFC that they're far from gold plated.

Who Sells Annuities In Australia?

Challenger is the largest provider of retail annuities in Australia, and some super funds and life insurers offer lifetime income products too. My view is about the product, not any one company.

So, Are Annuities Worth It?

Annuities aren't the worst thing on the planet, but I don't think they're the best. On the existing offerings, I wouldn't touch one. I don't think the return is worth the risk.

That said, for a very, very small number of people, I can see the allure, more so if someone is quite long in the tooth, worries deeply about outliving their money, and has no one to leave it to.

I don't think we're in the golden age of annuities. I do think we're in the golden age of super funds. Low-cost industry funds now offer account-based pensions that are cheap, flexible and yours.

I'm hopeful that someday soon someone will come up with a product that gives retirees total peace of mind for life, likely a blend of a pension and an annuity. If they do, you can buy one that day. Today's versions feel like a rickety prototype.

But the good news, and all you really need to know, is that you already have an annuity. It's better than any on the market. It's called the Age Pension.

It rises with inflation, has no expiry date, and if markets fall and your balance shrinks, it tends to rise to meet you.

What Does Advice Work Out That A Calculator Can't?

An annuity calculator gives you a payment. It won't tell you how the purchase changes your Age Pension now and at 84, what happens to a couple's two balances, what your family loses if you die early, or whether the same peace of mind is available without locking anything up. Advice puts real numbers to those.

I give one-off advice for a fixed fee: no commissions, no ongoing fees. The first consultation is $330, credited against the advice fee if you go ahead.

Next Step

See how I help with retirement advice, or book a consultation.

General advice warning: this article is general advice only and reflects my professional opinion. It has been prepared without taking into account your objectives, financial situation or needs.

Book A Consultation

If you do not need advice, you find out for $330, not $6,600.

  • 45 minutes with the adviser himself, not a junior
  • A fixed quote on the call, if advice is warranted
  • The $330 is credited in full if you proceed

Why $330 and not free? A free first meeting is usually paid for later, through ongoing fees. I would rather you paid once for my time and owed me nothing.

Book A $330 Consultation

Pay $330 now. A consultation, not an advice session. Reschedule up to 48 hours before.