Skip To Content

Four consultations a week. Book It

Podcast Transcript

Captain FI: How To Get Good Advice Without The Fees

Captain FI interviewed me for episode 40 of his podcast in 2023. We cover ongoing fees, choosing a super fund, SMSFs and quick wins beyond super.

Key Points

  • Andy says that, in his view, ongoing fees are the number one cause of poor outcomes for clients.
  • He argues you should pay for financial advice the way you pay an accountant, a doctor, a lawyer or a plumber, when you see them.
  • He calls superannuation the greatest wealth creation tool on the planet, noting that it cannot be accessed until 60.
  • He says there is no one perfect fund, and that good value matters more than the lowest fee.
  • He says fund returns should be compared net of tax, adviser fees and administration costs.
  • He says SMSFs are complicated and expensive to set up, run and close, and that he can rarely imagine a reason a client would benefit from one.
  • His three priorities are a top-performing super fund, a plan to minimise tax, and low-cost, high-quality products for investing outside super.

Where Andy Comes From

Captain FI: Andy, welcome. Tell us a little bit about yourself. Where you are from, and I believe you are currently in the big smoke of Sydney.

Andy: Very glad to be here. My name is Andy. I am originally from Queensland, from Toowoomba, Australia's second biggest inland city, I always love to tell people. I have been down here in Sydney for a number of years now and I run my business out of Sydney.

Captain FI: Ah, so a Queensland boy. So you must be NRL or league?

Andy: Yep. I enjoy watching NRL. Unfortunately for me, I go for the Newcastle Knights, which has not been the most profitable investment, but deep down I am a true bogan. I adore motorsport. I am a big fan of anything with two wheels, so I am a bit of a tragic for MotoGP particularly.

Captain FI: There you go. We have got that in common. You have obviously been in the financial advice game for a while. Why and how did you get into financial advice? What is your motivation?

Andy: I love listening to podcasts and looking at different financial planners' websites and the dark hole of humanity that is LinkedIn. I always love it when people answer this question with, oh, I do this because I just love helping people, or some frankly [nonsense] trope like that, that they wheel out. I come from a family of accountants, so I studied accounting at uni and I pretty quickly discovered that I had no interest in working as an accountant, and I fell into wealth management as a result of that. I was really lucky and fortunate that I spent most of my career at some pretty decent institutions like Macquarie Private Bank and Wilson HTM, as it was then known, which is one of the older stockbroking firms in the country. I feel like that gave me a pretty first-class apprenticeship in financial markets, advice, investments and that kind of stuff.

I must say that I did fall into the industry by accident, but I absolutely love what I do. I think it is the greatest job I could ever fall into. I love everything about financial markets and investments, and perhaps one of the things I like most about financial advice is that it is frankly not that difficult. If you have got the ability to look at things objectively, the answers are relatively simple. It is not actually a massively complex or big-brained exercise, as some people represent it to be. When you get down to brass tacks, it is quite a simple and logical industry.

Captain FI: It is refreshing to hear that from an expert. When I got into the FIRE community I probably tried to find ways to overcomplicate it myself, because I thought there is no way it could be this simple. When you distil it into one sentence, it is just live below your means and consistently invest. But we will get into that in a little bit. So how did you make the jump from working for those larger companies to doing financial advice at a personal level?

Why Andy Started His Own Business

Andy: My timing was absolutely excellent. I started my business on 1 July 2021, which for anyone in Sydney was about four days after we went into quite a lengthy lockdown, which was not quite desirable. After working at what I consider really high-quality investment houses and institutions, you could not help but notice the truly obscene levels of fees, the layers and layers of fees, and fundamentally the hopelessly conflicted position that advisors, and the companies they work for and represent, find themselves in. For all these purported high-octane strategies and cutting-edge solutions, whatever ostensible benefit was given to the client was thoroughly eroded by fees. It sounds a little self-preachy and high and mighty, but I genuinely believe that it does not have to be like that, that you really can give people advice without putting your own interests first, and that it is actually not that difficult to give good financial advice. There are many ways to do it a lot better. That was the rationale. I started my business in mid 2021 and I am coming up on two years now, and it has been really enjoyable. As you alluded to, I have some pretty strong opinions on the industry at large, so I do enjoy being able to call out what I perceive to be [nonsense] quite freely, which is obviously a lot harder to do when you are part of a business.

Captain FI: It is refreshing to hear people just saying it how it is. It must have been difficult in those organisations, as you say, where you have to toe the company line. I love being able to have my own voice and do what I want now post-FIRE. When you started your business, how do you actually do that? You obviously register an ABN, but how do you start a financial advice business? Surely that is super expensive.

Andy: It can be. Like anything, if you are willing to do a good chunk of the work yourself, it is a lot easier. A lot of it is going through the kind of process of setting up an accounting business. There are added complexities with financial advice. It is an intensely regulated industry, for good reason. As you mentioned, there is a register of financial advisors. There are only two kinds of people that I am aware of that are kept on public registers, and one of them happens to be financial planners. There is a lot of administrative work in the back end of the financial advice industry that a lot of people would not appreciate. You have to be a representative of an Australian financial services licence. I am part of an AFSL that I am on with another financial advisor who shares my opinion on the industry. [Editor: this has changed since recording.] I like to think I am about as independent as you could get, in the sense that my business and our AFSL has no relationship with any bank, any super fund, any insurer. We have a completely open menu that we can choose from for people, and we are as far removed from vested interests as you can be.

The Industry At Large

Captain FI: That is a great segue, because the next thing I wanted to ask was, having worked in the industry for over a decade, and now running into your third year of running your own business, what is your opinion on the advice industry at large?

Andy: I could sum it up pretty succinctly. I genuinely think it is a complete rip-off factory. That is not one place or anything, it is the industry at large, in my opinion at least. Fundamentally that is because it is hopelessly conflicted. In my personal opinion, 99% of the time when someone receives financial advice, it is designed to benefit the advisor more than the client. It sounds awfully exaggerated, but having done this for quite a long time, that is my genuine opinion.

There is a fantastic line that I love wheeling out all the time, by Charlie Munger, who is the 99-year-old right-hand man of Warren Buffett: show me the incentive and I will show you the outcome. That is the root cause, in my humble opinion. Financial advisors, by and large, and the financial services industry and the companies that comprise it, are hopelessly incentivised to put you in products that will pay them. The industry is intensely regulated, but all that really does is create layers of administration to get to the exact same outcome. You can look at the outcomes of the royal commission or anything before that, and it is not hard to see that the financial advice industry really prioritises its own interests ahead of clients. With legalese and financial jargon and terminology, it is not difficult to give people paralysis by analysis. The Productivity Commission says there are over 40,000 different options for your super when you factor in all the underlying investments. It is not hard to see that this is a big, impossible task. So you go and see someone and it sounds and looks great until you actually get under the bonnet and you realise it is a bit of a fee gouge in many instances.

Captain FI: It does not necessarily need to be super complicated, does it? A couple of basic options, a little bit of education about your risk tolerance and timeframe for investing, understanding a little bit about portfolio allocations and diversification. It is probably a conversation you could have quite succinctly with one of your clients, right?

Andy: Definitely. As I said earlier, the advice industry is intensely regulated, so there is a lot of administration for someone to say, look, this is what I think you should do, when products are involved. In my opinion it has created this whole industry that is there for rent-seeking behaviour. By that I mean if it is expensive and time consuming for someone to tell you where and what to invest in, they are going to try to recoup that cost. If you ask me what is the number one thing that leads to poor outcomes for clients, it is purely and simply ongoing fees.

Why Ongoing Fees Persist

Andy: In my business at least, it is incredibly rare that I would ever pitch someone an ongoing fee arrangement, because I think you can put a target on it as the root cause of a significant amount of poor outcomes for clients. If your advisor has two options, and one of them is a managed product that is top tier, probably one of the best investment solutions on the planet, but they are not going to get an ongoing fee out of it, or they can put you into some other mysterious lobster-pot portfolio of managed funds and they are going to charge you an annual fee out of it, there is a significant economic and personal financial incentive for them to use the latter option. A good medical analogy is that a lot of advisors are seeking to treat the symptoms and not the cure. If someone comes to you and says, tell me how to invest, tell me how to save tax, the whole industry is geared towards, we will definitely help you do it, but you are going to have to pay us a monthly retainer.

My philosophy is that you should pay for financial advice the same way you pay for advice from an accountant, a doctor, a lawyer or a plumber. You pay them when you see them. Do you pay your mechanic a retainer if they are not fixing your car? No. Do you pay a real estate agent a trailing commission after they have sold you the house? No. I think it is a bit ridiculous that the advice industry gets away with that. There are plenty of explanations as to why, but I cannot say I have ever heard a compelling one. Advisors will make you think that you need to be seeing them once a month, once a year, whatever. They might try to purport that they have got this magic portfolio of managed funds which is going to outperform everything else, which I say is completely not the case in my experience. Without sounding arrogant, I consider myself reasonably good at what I do, and if I cannot put together a portfolio that is better than a top-flight industry fund, I think it is quite ridiculous that my peers in the industry think they can.

Captain FI: I really like something you said there about do you pay your mechanic a trailing commission after they fix your car. It feels like that is the way a lot of things are going these days, with the subscription models.

Andy: A hundred percent. It is everything from cars to Netflix, and vehicles are going to that. The reason is quite simple. It is one of the world's greatest business models. Every self-made billionaire typically comes from one of two roads. They design a business that is SaaS, software as a service, or they are a hedge fund manager. The reason is that it is infinitely scalable. If I am a hedge fund manager or a financial advisor, and I am managing a hundred million dollars and I ratchet that up to half a billion dollars, it is not five times the cost. There is no marginal cost of production. If I am a pipe manufacturer and I sell five times as many pipes, my accounting costs will not increase and my marketing costs will not increase, but I have got to buy more raw materials, use more power and have more hands on the factory line. That is why it is so fabulously lucrative. If I am charging ongoing fees, and I would argue that in nine out of ten cases not doing any work, that means I can keep adding more and more revenue streams to this gravy train. There is an independent media outlet that publishes a report every year called the Tax Heroes, listing which enterprises get closest to that 30% effective tax rate, and I find it quite amusing that often it is fund managers. It is not because fund managers are devoid of public interest. The reason they pay an effective tax rate pretty close to the corporate rate is that you can only stuff so many corporate lunches into a circular key office, with a few Bloomberg terminals and a $2,000 office chair, and you pretty quickly run out of expenses. It is more indicative of how lucrative this model is. And it is [very] hard to divorce yourself from it. If you work in the industry, it is why people have these fabulous explanations for it all, because there is such a fantastic apple waiting at the end of the road. If you look at it objectively and think, is this actually good value for money, my take is no, it is not.

Captain FI: From the basic principle of saving money or cutting your costs on your path to financial independence, I am personally always on the lookout for things that are charging me ongoing fees, like Netflix, Spotify, maybe some insurances that I do not necessarily need anymore. When you are not actually getting something but you are still paying for it, it is very easy to let it sit there in the background and siphon money. [...]

Andy: Definitely. It goes back to that point earlier. You can have a roster of a hundred clients on your book, and they pay you a fee, and all you do is leave them in a portfolio of managed funds that rarely, if ever, changes. It is an amazingly lucrative business and it is pretty hard to turn that down when you are going through the industry. There is a lot of money to be made, and often you do not have to do a lot of work for it. It is a really difficult thing to divorce yourself from, that whole personal financial gain. But the positive is that for every problem with the industry, there are some simple, incredibly easy ways to go about righting the ship and setting yourself up really well.

Captain FI: So how did you divorce yourself from it, then? It feels like you have given away the secret sauce here, and it sounds like you could be making a lot more money if you just started charging trailing commissions. So why do you just give an upfront fee for service?

Andy: I do not want to pretend I am Jesus of Nazareth or anything like that, but I just get no satisfaction from it. Using the old rule of thumb, I do not charge percentage-based fees, but it is fairly standard in the industry. If someone has, say, half a million dollars or a million dollars of investments, a pretty standard fee would be 1% for the management of that. I just get no satisfaction from seeing a million-dollar client, who is paying you 10,000 bucks a year, and if they are just sitting in a managed account or a simple portfolio of stocks and managed funds that rarely if ever changes, sitting in front of that person at the end of the year and saying, hey, by the way, we did this, we probably underperformed the better super funds out there, you paid us 10 grand, and we are going to do the same thing next year, and the year after that. Maybe there is some tinkering around the edges.

The other thing is that when you first see an advisor, in many cases they can add a lot of value. You might have your super all over the place. It might not be structured correctly. Sorting it out at the beginning can really help people. That is going through, are you invested appropriately for your age and your distance to retirement and personal preferences? Are we saving tax in the right fashions? Are we planning for the future in the right fashions? All of the stuff at the start is generally really good. It is almost always people going into the wrong product, because it is paying that ongoing fee. I thought the first bit is fine and the rest of it is a bit of a rort. I would rather have a crack at doing it properly with client interests at heart than continue the status quo.

Why Super Matters, Even For FIRE

Captain FI: That is really positive, man. I think it will probably resonate with a lot of people in the FIRE community, because they are savvy consumers. You have talked a little about super and how setting it up correctly is important. It is probably something that does not get as much attention as it deserves in the FIRE community, because our timeframes are probably a bit shorter than your typical Australian planning for a 65-year-old retirement. What is so special about super, and why should people on the path to FIRE still be paying attention?

Andy: I think superannuation is the greatest wealth creation tool on the planet. There is nothing else like it, genuinely. That is for two reasons. A, superannuation has a tax structure which, to put it succinctly, is a tax dodge on the way in. It pays next to no tax while it is in there, and it is tax free on the way out. The caveat naturally is that you and I cannot access it until we are 60 years old, which, particularly for people in the FIRE community, can be a bit of an issue. Fortuitously there have been some law changes, namely around concessional contributions, which can make it a lot more useful for people on the FIRE path, in my opinion anyway.

The other fundamental thing that makes super stand on its own is, generally speaking, industry funds. You would be hard pressed to find a single example of anything that compares to it globally. The thing I always say to people is that there is no one perfect fund, and anyone who sits in front of you and purports that there is, is either stupid or lying, or perhaps both. But whilst there is no one perfect fund, you can pretty quickly narrow it down to the good ones, the average ones, the poor ones and the great ones. There is not one great fund, there are probably half a dozen or so. All it boils down to is, is the fund you are giving it to going to get you a really high return for a really low fee, and are they going to be able to continue to do that for the next 10, 20, 30 years? There are a million things you can unpack with respect to that. But when you look at the net returns from funds, industry funds are generally at the top of the pops.

What is often not well discussed is that whenever you see a fund return, it is net of taxes and net of fees. All the time I see products getting whirled around, whether it is a single investment or someone's claimed managed portfolio, and they will purport to have this return, but A, it is not net of tax, B, it is not net of advisor fees, and C, it is not net of administration costs that would typically be associated as well. So it is always important to compare apples with apples. Going back to it, if I recommend someone going to an industry fund, I am not going to charge them any ongoing fees, because I am not actually managing the money and there is no economic interest for me to do that. The lion's share of the advice industry does not really have any interest in doing that, because there is nothing in it for them. When you look at returns and the way they manage the money, it is second to none.

I did write a pretty critical article about one of the industry funds and actually met with the CIO after, and it completely changed my opinion on the fund. He had this great line. He said, we let anyone invest like a billionaire. Quite frankly that is what it does. If you put your funds in what I consider to be a top-flight industry fund, you can genuinely rest assured that your money is managed as well as any billionaire's on the planet. You are getting the level of service and sophistication that someone like Mohammed bin Salman or Bill Gates or Mike Cannon-Brookes would. You are really in the best of the best. It comes back to one of the most important tenets, which is that, for all intents and purposes, they are independent. They are not owned by a bank, they are owned by the members. Because of that, if they want to invest your money, they do not just default to using a subsidiary to manage the bond portfolio because that is good news for shareholders. They will go out and find the best of the best to do it, or they will do it in-house at really low cost.

Something I find very interesting is the notion that your local advisor, or even someone who works for a big multinational in the CBD of a state capital, is going to get a better investment than a 150 billion dollar fund is a joke. Buying investments is no different to buying fruit. If you buy wholesale, you get better prices. In addition to that, you get tickets to different leagues if you are in the large funds. If you are the world's greatest currency trader, or the world's greatest private equity manager or hedge fund manager, and I had, say, 150 clients and we pooled 10% of all their money and went to Mr Manager and said, would you please manage our 15 million dollars, that is a no, thank you, go away. But if you are a 150 billion dollar industry fund and you go to them and say we would like to allocate you 500 million, they will happily take it. Because for all intents and purposes the fund is independent, if that manager does not perform, they will sack them. If the fund can figure out that they can do it in-house at much reduced cost, they will do it. There are really fabulous investment managers out there that are worth their fees. The problem is that by the time it gets to an average person, it has gone through so many layers that you are not getting the best product, and there are so many palms greased along the way that any benefit from their outperformance has been eroded by fees. The Productivity Commission did a really good investigation into super years ago, and at the time of writing there were 40,000 different superannuation options. A lot of those are underlying investments, but it is crazy.

Captain FI: You said it before, and I will say it again: show me the incentive and I will show you the outcome.

Andy: Every time. The advice industry is by and large pretty motivated to pooh-pooh that idea, and some people might say, oh, he is an idiot, he does not know what he is talking about. But I have actually gone through it. With a lot of funds, the end of the annual report tells you who manages the money, a list of the managers, and one fund in particular, Sunsuper, which is now Australian Retirement Trust, goes a step further and publishes its investment portfolio on its website. In their balanced option you can go through and see every manager and every investment that they hold.

Typically when a financial advisor puts you in a portfolio, they will do it via something called a wrap product, which is just an investment account. They put you in that wrap and then select a bunch of managed funds. I thought, let us just have a look. This was Sunsuper, probably in 2021, I think. I went through and found the most expansive wrap menu, the investment product that had the biggest menu to choose from, I think it was 800 or so different funds. Then I compared that to Sunsuper. Let us be fair: you will often see in an industry fund, or any fund for that matter, someone like Goldman Sachs or Macquarie or Morgan Stanley, managers that also appear in the wrap product. It is important to note that you are not going to get the same price if you are an itsy-bitsy individual compared to a hundred billion dollar gorilla. They are going to beat down the manager's costs. But I thought, any manager that appears in the wrap menu, I will remove from the Sunsuper portfolio. Of the 69 investment managers Sunsuper had, for 61% of them you could not find the manager at all, not just the fund and the value for money, on what I found to be the broadest wrap portfolio. These are incredibly big-hitting US, Japanese, European and Australian managers that you cannot even access through an advisor, because they are absolute gorillas with no interest in managing small fry's money. They just want to go direct to the big funds. The reason they are employed is that they do something really well. They might be exceptionally good at managing a bond portfolio, or a property portfolio. And hypothetically, at least with industry funds, there is no corporate interest there. They are not defaulting to, this is a subsidiary of the bank, so we will give them that allocation. It is either perform and maintain your mandate, or get sacked.

For anyone who says it is just a rubbish investment product, I say, prove it to me, because you and I cannot go and access 61% of the managers. Of the 39% that we can access, I will bet you my left hand we are paying a higher fee than a 150 billion dollar fund can negotiate, because they have a significantly higher bargaining power. For anyone who defaults to pooh-poohing it, when you look into it and do a bit of research, you find it is quite the contrary. It helps everyone invest like a billionaire. There are plenty of examples of retirement tax structures globally that are comparable with super, but it is that industry fund model that you really do not find anywhere else. These funds are owned by the members, and by virtue of that, they tend to historically get a lot better results for their members, because they are incentivised to do so.

How To Choose A Super Fund

Captain FI: Knowing that, how do people go about actually choosing a fund? What are some of the factors that might make a fund appropriate?

Andy: Great question. There is no one perfect fund. If I look at what I consider a first-class A-plus fund, the notion that I could say with conviction that this fund is better than that fund, when we are talking about maybe 70 or a hundred different underlying managers and thousands of separate investments, is ridiculous. But first and foremost you want to make sure it is a low fee or a good fee. You want to make sure you are getting value for money. Something I personally think the FIRE community is often a little over-focused on is the lowest fee. You do not necessarily want the lowest fee, you want to get really good value. If you are getting a Ferrari at the price of a Toyota Corolla, it is a good deal.

What might help you figure out what fund is best for you is how old you are. Some funds are better at dealing with retirees. They have got more comprehensive strategies in place to make sure retirees are getting the tax-free earnings they are entitled to. It can depend on how big your balance is, and also how big your partner's balance is. It is not all that uncommon that I get clients with pretty substantial amounts of money in super, and I will say, these are what I consider the absolute two best funds. If it is not going to make a difference to the fees, why do we not choose two funds? If you had a race and you could back one horse, or back two if it is not going to cost you anything. Often you find there are funds that are complementary to each other. One fund might do a lot of investing in unlisted assets, infrastructure, property, private equity, private credit, and then you might have another fund that does not do a lot of that. It is not one or the other, but if you are fortunate enough to combine the two, it is fabulous.

There are some pretty simple ones as well. Do you need insurance? Some funds have cheaper insurance than others. That is a pretty motivating factor. There are a lot of industry considerations as well. If you work in particular industries, for example the military, public service or construction, some funds might appeal to you more. They might invest in projects that theoretically stimulate your industry. I would argue that is actually the complete reverse way to go about it. If you have got your retirement savings, the less correlated they are to your earning, the better. If you work in the mines and all you do is own mining stocks, you are too exposed to one thing. But for a lot of people that is a really important thing. Another thing is whether your employer has negotiated a good deal. Occasionally you will find that a retail fund, which I consider garbage, has been negotiated by your employer, and it actually turns out to be a really good option. Insurance is often the dictating factor there as well. If you have really good insurance because you work for a business that has negotiated it, keeping that account open is a real priority.

Then the other most common one, which I see so much advertising for, is the more personal trait. The obvious example is ethical investing, which is a real focus for a lot of people, and often that can be a dictator. It is a pretty deep pool when you actually drill into it, and there are some pretty big discrepancies between the funds. For some people it might be a gender equality thematic, or a faith-based preference. More often than not it is environmental. There are different levels to attack that problem. A couple of funds out there advertise being focused on gender equality, females in particular, and I would argue, why would you not just select one of the better industry funds that does the same thing? The way they do that is that they are quite rigorous in interrogating the actual underlying managers: how many females do you have in your firm, what positions are they in, what is the gender diversity like in your executive team. Similarly with environmental, social and governance, ESG, and then SRI, socially responsible investing. When you drill into what underpins that, I could talk for an hour on that.

Fundamentally, what is your own preference? Do you want a fund that is headquartered in your state? Are you really parochial about that? Or do you like the colour of one? It is not even a joke. If there are three funds and they are all top flight and all within half a percent of each other, you are not going to do yourself a disservice.

One of the things I really do focus on, particularly with funds, is size. Size matters. The regulator has been pretty active, saying for years and years: the nurses union in Queensland had their own super fund, the nurses union in Victoria had one, the electricians in WA had one. If you are an electrician in Western Australia or in South Australia, your superannuation needs are not any different whatsoever. So there is a lot of consolidation in the super space and it is fantastic. One of the things I always run an eye over is that the smaller the fund, the more likely it is to be swallowed up by one of the big ones. I do try to make sure I am not going to recommend a fund that in eight months' time is going to get swallowed up by a fund that I would give a grade of A-minus, when I could have gone to an A-plus to begin with. It really is horses for courses, but I would say the two biggest dictating factors are insurance and what stage of life you are in, because some funds are really good for young people but might not be as cutting edge when it comes to retirees, particularly with insurance.

Captain FI: [...]

Andy: Within these top-flight funds, once you explain to someone, look, this is the kind of tilt that these funds have, one might manage money in a slightly different fashion, they might do nothing internally and give everything to the best of the best, and that is why their fees are slightly higher than another fund, or one fund might steer clear of unlisted assets altogether, it depends on personal circumstance. But it is not that hard. You can look at what the top 10 are over a five or seven year basis and there are a lot of similar names in there. If you do want to understand why the particular fund you have selected is the best for you, it can help. What I always say to people is that school grades are a really good way to communicate ratings for funds. I might give one fund an A-plus and another an A-minus because of slight peculiarities about what they do or how they go about it. That does not mean the A-plus will outperform. They are all really good products. It is not a zero-sum game. It is not, I picked the wrong one and now I am destitute. You might find one slightly outperforms on a 10-year basis, but equally you have got a great return as well. I do not want to create the impression that if you do not pick the right one your life is over and you are begging in the street in your seventies. It is not the case at all.

It remains to be seen how a lot of these funds will adjust to being bigger and bigger. Part of what makes industry funds so good is that they have been around for 30 or 40 odd years, and during that time they have built some phenomenal infrastructure and processes and people and strategies. But managing 60 billion is no mean feat, and when you look at the wall of money that goes into super, it will be interesting to see how some of them adjust to managing 500 billion, which a lot of them will theoretically get to, particularly with the regulators saying we want to see fewer funds and more consolidation. I think that is something to watch over the next 10 or 15 years, how these funds adjust from being big to really big. Some are better prepared than others.

Fees, Value And Wrap Accounts

Captain FI: It will have an interesting impact on the fees, because my understanding is that the larger the fund, theoretically the better deals they should be able to get. It is the same as you mentioned before, you are basically wholesaling, buying in bulk. Fees are pretty important. I want to read something out from one of my favourite blogs, Eli's Blog, Passive Investing Australia. He wrote an article called How 1% Fees Cost You A Third Of Your Nest Egg. I will read a little excerpt. He mentions an annual fee of 1% of your total assets is really 10% of your annual return. Due to inflation, a 1% asset-based fee is over 16% of your average annual portfolio gains in real terms. The result is that a 1% fee results in a loss of about one third of your super balance. A 1% asset-based fee in retirement reduces your 4% drawdown rate to a 3% drawdown rate in terms of actual ability to spend. Once you combine the reduction of a third of your nest egg at the end of your accumulation, as well as the loss of a quarter of your income generated from that shrunken nest egg, your retirement income has fallen by half. That is pretty crazy, man. To me that sounds like fees play a huge part in how you would select a fund. From your opinion as a qualified financial advisor, how important are fees, and how can you make sure that you are getting good value?

Andy: Fees are crucial. Technically the most important thing, the biggest dictator of your return, is how the money is invested. If you sit in cash versus high growth, it is a different result. But as you can tell from my views, fees are unbelievably important. It is one of the symptoms of the industry as a whole that the amount of jargon and layers is astonishing. It is not about the lowest fee. Just because one fund might charge you half a percent and the other fund charges you 0.6%, it does not mean the half-a-percent fund is immediately going to do 0.1% better. But you have to be in that good-value window, which I would say most of the top-performing funds, one hundred percent are.

More important than just the fee of your fund or your investment is what other fees you are getting stripped. If you go and see an advisor and they put you in a portfolio of managed funds, which I would argue are probably pretty mundane and not going to do a great job, it is not just the cost of those funds, which, let us reiterate, if you are a 200 billion dollar fund you are getting cheaper fees than any person off the street. Secondly, you are going to have to pay an administration fee to access those funds via what is called a wrap or an investment product of that nature, or a retail super fund, whatever it might be. You are more than likely going to pay advisor fees, which at the start you might get some benefit from, but going forward I struggle to imagine how they are justifying the costs. You might be paying other fees as well: a Statement of Advice fee, an implementation fee, a brokerage fee. There are new ones being invented every day. It is aggravating, to say the least.

Every financial product gives you what is called a product disclosure statement, which is like the terms and conditions on your iPhone, and I dare you to read it. It is incredibly boring. But there is a big box in every single one, from the regulator, that says a 1% difference in fees can make, I believe it is a 20% difference to your end balance. That is the thing, 1% does not sound big, but small percentages make incredible differences in dollars. That is why the advice industry as a whole really likes charging clients percentage-based fees. It is twofold. A, it is an infinitely scalable model, which is extremely attractive. But it is also that if you say to someone who has got 2 million bucks, or half a million, or even $250,000, hey, you are going to pay us 1% and we are going to manage your money, you think, oh, okay, that is fair. But if they actually said to you, by the way, we are going to take two and a half thousand dollars from you, or you are going to pay us $10,000 a year, or $20,000 a year, people recognise that more. That is why the regulator requires in a Statement of Advice that you actually display the dollar fee being charged. Same with product disclosure statements. They do not just show you the percentage-based fee, they tell you the actual dollar fee being charged.

Even within your fund there are different kinds of fees. Even a top industry fund typically has two. One is an admin fee, totally fair, because they have got to have call centres, email, a working website and audits. Then there is an investment management fee as well. You want low fees, not necessarily the lowest, because there are some truly horrific products out there that do not claim to charge incredibly low fees and they are just dismal. If you can get in that good-value window, it is money that is going to continue to be invested, not ripped out. There are 40,000 different options, and I do not know, 130 odd MySuper registered funds or something, so the discrepancy is huge. It is not just the fee of your fund, it is also, what else are you getting done for? Are you paying advice fees you are getting zero value for? Are you paying admin costs because that product benefits the advisor, not you? Are you paying more than you should because you are buying your groceries from the 7-Eleven as opposed to going to the wholesaler direct, I suppose, would be an analogy.

Captain FI: I just want to point out, because I have read that standard line, a 1% fee results in a 20% lower balance, and I was like, huh. I think it is important to note the timeframe as well. I have got Eli's website up here and I am looking at the graph he has done from his modelling, and that 20% reduction is around the 25 year mark, whereas the modelling he has done is on a more realistic career of 40 years, where you start in the workforce somewhere between 20 and 25 and you retire at 65.

Andy: Further to that, if one top-performing fund is charging, say, 0.55% for its balanced option and another fund is charging 0.77% for its balanced option, that is okay, that is fine. They probably go about it in slightly different ways. One fund might internalise more, or one fund might use more costly investment strategies, which theoretically are better. But when there are big disparities, if you are paying north of 2% for a fund, my question would be, in what universe is that going to benefit you? It is not hard to get a low-cost fund. And as you say, it is over time, because superannuation is for most people the biggest asset outside the family home, and it is in there for a long time. The earlier you catch it, the less the effect.

Another thing on the fee discussion that can really savage people's balances is insurance costs. They did bring some new laws in to protect people around that. But typically you will find that if people have three or four funds, because you signed up when you joined a new employer, which is a pretty common thing to do, they might have three or four different funds that are all paying different insurance costs and all doubling up on that administration fee cost. Maybe some of them are good and some of them are pure rubbish. Something someone said to me once, which I thought was great, so I have stolen it, is, would you let your employer choose your house or your car or what bank you are with? Because ostensibly that is what you are doing with your super. I am not inferring that they get a benefit for it, but there is a whole sales channel in financial services called corporate super, where funds go around to employers and say, we want to be the default fund for your company, and here is why we think we should. Some of those funds are probably really good funds, and I guarantee you some of them are [poor].

Captain FI: The takeaway there is that they are not tailored for your personal situation. You have fairly comprehensively explained a huge number of factors that people need to consider for their personal circumstances when they go about choosing a fund. If you are just jumping onto a default bandwagon, you are basically missing that whole process.

Andy: A hundred percent. There is a really high chance that you are already in one of what I consider the top-performing funds, which is fine. But your HR professionals or your people and culture professionals, whatever you want to call them, are not qualified financial advisors. They do not pretend to be. If you have got a really good salesperson representing a really poor fund, maybe they will get through and get the default option. It is less of a problem now than it used to be, because there have been a few changes to the way workplaces and super funds interact. Namely, there are fewer default insurances, which savage people's balances over the long term, and that was one of the key things the Productivity Commission found, a real handbrake on people's retirement balances. Also your super is more likely to follow you now. If you are in your twenties, thirties or even forties, it is out of sight, out of mind. A pretty regular reason for people to get advice from me is that they come and see me with three or four funds, and maybe one or two of them are brilliant and two of them are garbage, and consolidating is a pretty rational first step.

Industry Funds, Unlisted Assets And Passive Investing

Captain FI: You said something a moment ago which made my eyeballs pop out a little. You were comparing two funds, one with 0.55% fees and one with 0.77%. Those sound like still high numbers to me, because outside of super, on the brokerage platforms, we have just seen a few of the players in Australian shares dramatically lower the management expense ratios, making index investing even cheaper than it was before. The question is, active versus passive: why should it be different in super, and why are the fees so much higher when you are investing in super compared to your brokerage account?

Andy: A hundred percent. Australians pay 30 billion in super fees alone every year, and I am not sure whether that includes advisor fees. I suspect it does not. This is where I differ a little from the standard FIRE playbook. I think it is hilarious how on the money 99% of the stuff that is self-directed, people in the FIRE camp get bang on. But I always say to people, and this is just my personal opinion, passive investing is the second best way you can ever invest your money. You are never going to turn around and be rueful the day you used a low-cost, index-based approach. It is a really good way to manage money. This is where superannuation is different. It is not just that it is a really good tax haven. Some of the participants in it are owned by the members. I challenge you to find another mutual society. There is one really big one that most people would be aware of, but apart from that there are not many left. And yet you have a bunch of them in super. Mutuals represent member interest better.

What makes super different is, for instance, if you invest in a bog-standard high-growth index-based passive approach, you are going to invest in different things to a high-growth investment option in a top-performing super fund. What do I mean by that? Industry funds, or a consortium of them, own, I believe, every single international airport in the country, or at least a share of them, excluding Canberra, which is privately owned. That is one of those cases where every time a plane lands you get paid. Same with the ports. Every time a ship docks you get paid. If you are in a passive investment, you do not get exposure to those kinds of investments. Same thing with property. You will find that good super funds own reams and reams of property, everything from pubs to medical centres to often very attractive buildings tenanted by government tenants, someone like the ATO or a state government. Then another one that is coming more and more into the fold is private credit, which is again unlisted. If you stick to a passive approach, I do not think you can turn around and be disadvantaged. I think you will do fine. But that is what makes super different. There is nowhere else on the planet where you can give someone $1,000, $10,000 or $5 million and get a ready-made product of cutting-edge investment managers that are all selected independently, and a lot of that is done in house.

What you tend to find is that in any good super fund, take for example the S&P 500, it is pretty hard to add value after you are managing an investment like that, because it is quite an efficient market and it is so followed. Compare that to someone like Japan, where managers can often actually add a bit of value because there are some really interesting things with corporate governance in Japan, which makes it quite an interesting place to invest. Same thing with China. It can pay to have someone running a ruler over that and finding the better investments, because it does come with its own peculiarities, just the nature of the government and that kind of stuff.

What it goes back to is that if, to get that person who is trying to pick the winners and dodge the losers, you pay advisor fees, admin fees and layers of fund fees, and at the same time you are paying double because you are retail and not going through the wholesale channels, are you going to get any benefit? Absolutely not. It is just going to get eroded and you are going to get a lesser market return. However, if the only person between you and that superstar bond manager, hedge fund manager or property manager is your super fund, and your super fund is charging an admin fee of 78 bucks a year, you are probably going to see a bit of advantage there. If that particular manager did not perform well, they are not owned by the super fund, they will get sacked and someone else will do it, or they will just move it to passive. It is like anything in life. It is not one or the other. That is part of what I discuss with people. Some people come with the mindset, I am all about the index approach, it is the way I understand, I love everything about it. I say that is fine, here is what I think the better index products are. Some of the index super products are pretty nauseating, but equally there are really good ones as well.

This is of particular interest for the FIRE community. Outside of super I struggle to find a more attractive way to invest money than putting it in a simple index ETF. It is low fee, it is low tax, it is low turnover, it is brilliant. But what I tend to find, because I get heaps of FIRE people come across, is that if you do have a significant amount of money in passive investments outside of super, it can be a really good diversification to get a super fund that does quite a bit of active management, because you might be investing in things you are otherwise not exposed to, be it airports, property, private credit or long-short strategies. That is really complementary. It depends on the person. Some people just do not want to go that way, and that is totally fine. But anecdotally I think it is a perfect combination. If underneath that 0.75% balanced fee is some of the greatest minds in investing who time and time again really deliver value, that is fine. If underneath that 1% management fee is a bunch of low-grade, third-tier managers that are affiliated with the bank or financial services business that runs that super, get rid of it. It depends what you are paying for.

Captain FI: Just exploring some of those alternative investments. You have mentioned things like airports, and I am aware there are different investment groups that have things like toll ways and other infrastructure. Can you tell us a little more about these unlisted assets and the role they play in super?

Andy: It is a personal gripe of mine, which is a fairly long list, let us be honest. One of the most common things that advisors will say, or anyone who has a vested interest, is that XYZ funds are cooking the books on the returns of their unlisted assets. If you and I own Sydney Airport, for example, and it is traded on the ASX, there can be no argument as to what it is worth. It is worth whatever it traded at at the close. Where it gets more nuanced is once that thing is taken private. It is up to the fund to determine what it is worth. There are very stringent processes in place. It is almost always done by accounting firms, ideally one of the big four. They will have a methodology, whether it is comparing like for like or multiples of the profit it made a year. It is a common thing you hear from advisors, who say, oh no, they are rubbish, they are just imagining the value of the Port of Melbourne or something. Then the exact same advisor will go and put a portion of your money in a private credit fund, or an unlisted infrastructure fund or unlisted property. Some advisors quite active in the media, I find it hilarious, are always talking about, this is the commercial property trust that we are doing and this is the yield on the properties. It goes back to that point: do I want to invest in a property portfolio that is going through my advisor, through an admin fee, cut up into little retail portions and finally goes to the manager, or do I just want to go direct through my 150 billion dollar super fund? I will take the latter for me personally. So first of all, I would always take that with a grain of salt, because it is a common line wheeled out by the industry.

The other more interesting thing with these unlisted assets is that a lot of these funds are 50 or 60 billion, some are up to 200 billion plus. Once you get to those sizes it can get more difficult to manage money, and it is a uniquely Australian problem. Australia is a nation of houses and holes, and the ASX reflects that. A lot of banks, which are exposed to property, and a lot of miners. There are some fantastic quality miners on the ASX, but outside of that, I think it is 2% of stocks globally or something. It is a minnow on the world stage. One of the problems super funds have is that they have this wall of money coming in. For some funds it is a billion dollars a month, for some it is more, and they have got to put that cash somewhere. If you are an Australian super fund, all of your members want to get paid in Aussie dollars and their retirement needs are going to be in Aussie dollars. You might think, I will just invest in the States, where it is really easy to do that, but then you are taking on loads of currency risk. So you have got this issue where they do want to keep a big foot in Australia. You want about 20 or 30% of your money, depending on your risk profile, in Aussie stocks. But as I alluded to, there are fantastic miners on the ASX and really high-yielding banks, and there is a handful of other companies, and once you go down the list to the 200th company the market cap is not that big. They are in a bit of a bind because they have got all this money and they need to put it to work, and you have really got no choice but for it to be really heavy on the top 50 or top 100. That is what I was talking about earlier. Some of these funds are better prepared for the next 20 years or so. It is the exact same thing as the 1% of fees. It takes a long time to get from 1 billion to 6 billion, but as you are growing every year, that gets bigger. It is like a hockey stick graph.

A lot of funds do like the element of these unlisted assets because you are seeing certain businesses, particularly infrastructure, getting taken private off the stock exchange. A lot of that was a function of the low-interest-rate world, which some people argue is done and some people argue we are going back to. A big part of that was that you were getting less than 1 or 2% on your government bonds and you needed reliable cash-generating assets, so you were happy to buy a toll road or a bridge or an airport or an office block, because it is a strong, reliable income. There is a good argument that if interest rates stay where they are, which plenty of intelligent people say they will and plenty say they will not, going forward, particularly for these big funds, if you can keep a foot in the Australian dollar by holding these big assets, which you can pour money into and also load up with debt, which can really enhance the return, a lot of it is a function of keeping exposure in Australian dollars, a lot of it is a function of trying to diversify, as more and more stocks are more volatile, and fundamentally it is preparing for being that 200 or 500 billion. You see some funds really beefing up their internal capacity. They are opening offices in Shanghai, London, New York, Zurich, you name it, and the basis is they are trying to get ready for when that comes so they do not have to go and pay some rather expensive manager. Macquarie is one of the biggest infrastructure managers on the planet, when they can just do it themselves in house.

There is one other silver bullet that the industry funds have. They have a business called IFM Investors, which is a consortium of funds, I think about 10 or 13 of them, all industry funds. It is the same design as Vanguard. It is a not-for-profit entity. They charge us the lowest fees they possibly can, and some of those funds are just fantastic and you cannot get them outside an industry fund. The actual IFM business itself, which is owned by the funds, is worth a lot of money. It comes back to, it is not one or the other, but it really does pay when you take a long-term view. However, it is extremely important that everyone is held honest on their returns, and I would say we have a fairly decent regulator that at least tries to do that. Let us not forget that there is one side of the political divide that is pretty vocal about not being a fan of industry funds. There is a lot of scrutiny that these funds go through year in, year out. They went through the royal commission too and came out with a clean bill of health. It is a fair argument, a common line wheeled out, how realistic are these valuations? I would say it is a very fair question, but what is a lot more indicative is who is asking that question and why. They really just want to do it so they can put you in a portfolio which, if they are half good at what they do, will have a ton of unlisted assets in it anyway.

What Andy Thinks About SMSFs

Captain FI: Might be opening a can of worms here, but we have talked about wrap accounts through advisors, we have talked about retail funds and some of the benefits of industry super funds. What about self-managed super funds, the old SMSF? Most of the time when I hear SMSF, it is somebody trying to spook me through my super, so I have probably already tarnished it. But what can you tell us about SMSFs?

Andy: I have dealt with a lot of SMSFs over the years. Whenever you work as a stockbroker, those kinds of businesses are typically very biased towards SMSFs, because it means the business can design a product that has a lot of managed accounts, run by the brokers, and it is a real gravy train for the business. The answer is simple. I would say 99% of the time, if someone is telling you to set up an SMSF, it is in their interest and not yours, or they are just hopelessly unaware of what better things are out there. Whenever you hear horror stories with super funds, nine out of ten times SMSFs are involved. They are complicated, they are expensive. They are expensive to set up, expensive to operate and expensive to close down. I deal with them all the time and it is almost the same thing every time: I am in this complicated piece of garbage, please help me get out of it. It takes quite a while.

Another problem with SMSFs is that a common intention of people is to access property via them. I have a bias, I have always worked in stockbroking houses, so I have a real bent towards listed investments as opposed to direct property, but super and property, in my opinion, are like oil and water. The two just do not mix. They are horrible to combine. By and large SMSFs are expensive, they are complicated, and they typically expose you to less consumer protection. Going back to the example of the financial advisor putting you in a portfolio of funds, they have got to go through an investment wrap. In order to be one of the 800 odd funds on that product's list, you have to prove that you are not doing illegal stuff and that you have a rating agency behind you. As soon as you get into SMSF territory, by and large you can invest in whatever you want. You can buy a collectible car, a coin collection, stocks or whatever. So it is a lot riskier. It is also inherently complicated, and fundamentally they do not do anything that you cannot get through a decent fund. If you want an active approach and to play a part in managing your funds, wonderful, there is probably a really good industry fund that can help you do that, whether it is buying ETFs yourself or taking your own approach to the infrastructure fund or the shares fund. It is purported that SMSFs give people more control, and to that I say, not in my opinion. It actually gives you a lot less control, because you are a lot more reliant on having an advisor and an accountant, and there are prohibitive costs and complication. There is no compelling reason to maintain one. As I say, I have dealt with them throughout my career and I still get clients with SMSFs all the time, and more often than not the question is, do I still need this? The answer we get to at the end of the process is absolutely not.

The other thing with an SMSF is that it is not impossible, but a lot harder to find, just do it for me, set and forget. In the admin fee from a super fund, they are doing your tax return and handling all the administration. When you are in an SMSF you have got to do it yourself, which you might get wrong, or you have got to pay an accountant to help you. I always find it terrifying that you could take one person to two different advisors and get radically different quotes for what is literally the exact same piece of work. Accountants are a lot less salesy than financial advisors, but with a lot of the firms that focus on SMSFs you can see a pretty wide spectrum of fees. It might be as low as a thousand bucks a year, or it could get as high as four or five, and that is just the accounting cost. Before I go on too much, I very seldom could even imagine a reason someone would actually benefit from an SMSF. I can think of lots of reasons why advisors would benefit. I cannot think of many, if any, why a client would, and that is after working with them for a long time.

Captain FI: Okay. So a red flag firmly planted over SMSFs.

Andy: Yes. There is also a loophole where you can get some very salacious commission payments with property. If anyone is trying to sell you a property, and for heaven's sake an off-the-plan property, via an SMSF, I would be extremely wary of that person. The regulator has been pretty intense in communicating that they are not very stoked on advisors that go around recommending SMSFs. Some advisors are a bit scared of recommending them, because the regulator actually takes an interest in which firms are recommending them by the bucketload, because historically they tend to result in higher costs and lower outcomes for clients.

Super Myths

Captain FI: What are some other myths that exist around super?

Andy: Some common ones that I am always complaining about. People think, they are always changing the goalposts, which is fair, they are. I hear a lot of people who really like the government's money. The truth is they are always changing the goalposts and they will continue to. But what they are more than likely going to change is getting money into super, not getting it out, because it is such a lucrative way to save tax and build wealth. You have got think tanks and both sides of politics talking about just how much of a black hole for tax purposes super is. There are actual changes to the law which mean some people in certain circumstances might not have to focus as much on super in their younger years, because there are some tax concessions that make it really efficient to migrate wealth into super once you are in your forties or fifties and you are more comfortable with that timeframe. The trade-off for super is not one to ignore. You cannot access it. It is so hard to access that you can declare bankruptcy and they cannot get at your super. That is how lucrative it is, and protected it is. But you cannot access it. They are going to continue to change the laws around it, but for most Australians it is still going to be a fantastic way to build wealth.

One of the other ones I have always had a bit of a bugbear with is that they should get rid of super funds and it should just be managed by the Future Fund. The Future Fund is there to back up the defined benefit pensions of government employees. That is absolutely not the case, because you do want more than one option. You do want competitive tension between different funds, which will get better outcomes and push them to get higher returns and lower fees. And secondly, the Future Fund is designed very differently from a super fund. They have only got, I think, about 17% or something in Australian equities. The whole point is that they do not want to be correlated to the Australian economy. Second to that, their portfolio is not designed to be as liquid as a super fund. They are a couple of the myths I hear. On that first one, it is locked away for a long time, which is not something to ignore. But it is about making sure you do not waste the opportunity. It might be planning to attack your superannuation more in five or 10 years. There is nothing like it.

Captain FI: Super is one aspect. It is a pretty big aspect, but it is just one part of financial advice. If you are interested in FIRE, your early retirement eventually becomes a typical retirement and you will eventually get access to your super, so it is something you need to pay attention to. But just quickly on the other side, what are some other areas of financial advice that you would concentrate on to get some quick wins for your clients?

Quick Wins Beyond Super

Andy: Often some of the simplest solutions are the best. Helping people understand whether there are ways we can save tax is a really common and really easy one. Helping people make decisions, should I invest outside of super or inside super, or a combination of the two. The more complicated someone's scenario is, the more you can do. If you see someone who has a really disparate income to their spouse, or who owns a business, or has a windfall gain from an inheritance or an asset sale, the more going on for someone, the more levers a financial planner can pull. I know I have conveyed a pretty grim take on the financial services industry, but it is not hard to give good financial advice. It is really not. I would love to say that I am the smartest guy in Australia and it is super complicated. It is actually pretty simple. All you want to do is save tax efficiently, and there are simple ways to do that. The tricky thing with financial advisors is to think of them like GPs. They are a jack of all trades, master of none. I am in no way, shape or form a tax accountant. I can give general advice on how to save tax, but you really do need to see an accountant if you have complicated tax affairs.

Outside of that, it is investments outside of super. I am a huge fan of passive investing, particularly outside of super. It is low tax, they are not constantly buying and selling, so we are not getting hit with capital gains. Super low fee, very complementary to a lot of what we try to do within super. Then helping people understand how to structure those things. Do you want it in your name, your partner's name, is perhaps an entity like a trust or a company on the cards, do you want to invest for kids or grandkids, and how should one go about that? Pretty simple solutions again. My philosophy on all of this is you should just pay for advice the same way we pay for everything else, when you use it. I would say often people do not need financial advice. Sometimes I see people who are 99% of the way there, so we will do an hour review and talk about some general concepts, and they are fine. They do not need a Statement of Advice. It is not going to add anything to their world. But let us say you do go down the road of getting an SOA, and common reasons for that are that you have just gone through a life event, maybe you had kids, or you are approaching retirement, or you have started earning a much larger income, or you have paid off your house. Generally speaking, once you put it all together, you really should not need to seek it again, unless you want to, for maybe three, five or ten years. Once you are set up in a good product investment-wise and super-wise, and you have a clear plan as to how you are going to save tax and protect your assets, you should not need to pay someone a retainer, because you have XYZ looking after your personal investments for a very fair fee and you have ABC looking after your investments in super for a very fair fee. If you do need tax advice ongoing, your accountant will do that.

Good things to look for in financial advice if you do have a lot going on: retirement is obviously a pretty big one for a lot of people. I am a sucker for reading books and blogs from other advisors, I cannot help myself, and a good line I heard from one was that planning a retirement is like playing a game of chess, except you only have one chance at it, which is not totally true, because you can always change whenever you want. But it can pay to get advice there to make sure you are doing all the right things, because you do not know what you do not know.

Captain FI: We have focused on a few of the shadier-looking areas of financial advice. What are some of the good areas of financial advice, and what are the benefits that getting a Statement of Advice can have on someone's financial health?

Andy: If it is done right, and it is not that hard, you can really set yourself up. If you are in a top-performing fund for 20 or 30 years, you will retire with a lot of money. If you get someone who can review your situation and figure out when and why and how you are going to use super as a tax structure, you can save a fortune in tax. The exact same applies with investing outside of super. If you set it up right at the start, it can make a massive difference. It is not all that dissimilar from super, where there are thousands of products and a million different competing interests buying for your attention with respect to personal investments. If you get set up initially, you may well find that you get really good dividends over the long term. It is not a zero-sum game. If you choose one particular manager that I do not think is as good as another, it does not mean you are going to be bankrupt and everything is ruined. It is more that perhaps you have paid a little more in fees, or perhaps under the bonnet this company does some rather rogue things to generate returns, so what appears on face value to be a really low-cost product actually has a few spooky things going on under the bonnet. It does not mean it is not going to work, you might just not be aware of it.

One of the other things that is not well communicated is that everyone seems to think, if you have got heaps of money, you should not be in a simple super fund and a simple investment strategy. When you tend to find that is actually the best thing to do, whether you have $6 million in financial assets or 160 grand, often you will find the solutions are not all that different, depending on how it is structured. I would also punch home one of the benefits of the Australian system: everyone has super, more or less, and by virtue of that everyone can access all of these really low-cost, really high-performing ways to insure yourself, save tax and invest for the future. In the last 18 months or so there have been one or two things that have come out with respect to personal investing which make it super easy to set that up long term. If you know when and why and how you are going to do things for the next five or 10 years, you have got a plan, fantastic, you are not leaving anything on the table. It can set you up for what we are all out here for, which is so we do not have to work for the money, so you can spend your time doing what you choose to do.

Andy's Top Three Priorities

Captain FI: Financial independence, that is the goal. It has been an awesome chat. I have only got a few more questions. Putting on your hat as a bloke on his own journey to financial independence, what are your top three tips, or top three strategies, in terms of getting the best bang for your buck?

Andy: Make sure you are in a top-performing super fund. That is number one. You are not overpaying your fees and you are not in a poor investment product. Number two, make sure you are saving tax where you can. The Australian system has some incredibly low-hanging fruit where you can either save tax or boost your returns, and similar to paying off debt, when you save tax it is a guaranteed return. It does not matter what markets do, you get that money no matter what. Number three, if you can set up your investments correctly at the start, which is incredibly easy to do, you will be in the arena where you do not have to pay prohibitive ongoing costs. One, find a good super fund. Two, have a plan as to how you are going to minimise tax. For a lot of people maybe that is not possible, but for a good proportion of the population it is quite achievable. And thirdly, if you are investing outside of super, which I think a lot of people should, make sure you do it via a really low-cost, high-quality product, which I am pretty certain a good portion of the listeners already do, if not all of them.

Captain FI: You mentioned you are a big fan of reading blogs, listening to podcasts and books. Do you have any top recommendations for learning resources?

Andy: Not particularly. I am like a bad gambler with forums and all that. What I find very entertaining is that I do not think there has ever been so much good information and so much rubbish information out there at the same time. If you are getting advice on a forum, it is highly likely that the person typing that comment may be all over it and 100% correct, but they also might not be. The pain in the neck is that if you go and see a professional, as we have discussed for a long time, I do not think they are necessarily going to put your interest first. So I think the best thing you can do, if you are in a really top-performing super fund, is to use the resources they have, and they are getting better and better at this, which I think is wonderful. They have really good resources online about what is going on in investment markets and how you should think about that, and really good fact sheets on, what happens to my super when I die, and that kind of stuff. Granted, they are not independent in the sense that they do want to retain their members, but they are also not trying to flog you an insurance product that is owned by the bank, or a mortgage affiliated with the product provider. A good super fund is a wealth of information, particularly with their own podcasts for updating market performance, and I love a lot of the stuff they are putting out.

Thirdly, there is a resource done by, naturally, my website, Independent Wealth Advice. One of the other really good ones I think is ASIC's Money Smart. It is like an online Wikipedia, if you will, of Aussie finance and all the things that make it up: managed funds, mortgages, insurance, super, et cetera. I think they do a pretty good job of making it readable. Whenever you have a question you want to try to find a couple of different places to answer it, but I am a big fan of Money Smart. I also quite like Super Guide. Again, show me the incentive and I will show you the outcome. People like Choice and Super Consumers Australia are not a lobby group or anything like that. They represent consumers, and astoundingly they tend to be closer to the money, so to speak. And then just anecdotally, I am really focused on markets, and I just love Twitter for that reason. The amount of pretty well regarded investment professionals on Twitter is great. There are a lot of morons on there as well, myself included. But on entertainment value, I think the investment feedback you get on particular stocks on Twitter is underappreciated.

Captain FI: I have been blown away by some of the conversations. I have been able to get in touch with people who run these companies, and when I have had guys and girls come on the show from companies like Six Park and Stockspot and other investment brokerage firms, often I have just reached out via Twitter or Instagram, and they are willing to talk to me. You never know unless you give it a go, right?

Andy: Exactly. I am the exact same. I have had conversations with and met people via Twitter that I otherwise would not have. I find it very entertaining. I think Money Smart is a brilliant resource, and so is a top-flight super fund.

Captain FI: [...]

Andy: Just on that, super funds charging you 0.7 or 0.8, that is not necessarily a bad deal, because fees matter, fees really do, but just because a fund charges half a percent more does not mean its return is half a percent less. There are honestly phenomenal funds out there that will charge you close to 1%, but what you are getting for that is an incredibly good investment solution. You cannot say carte blanche that just because a fund charges half a percent more, it returns half a percent less. It is the value you get for that. There are funds that I love that charge 0.7 odd percent, and I think people get cracking value for that. That is all inclusive. That is everything. There are no advisor fees or anything lying in there.

Captain FI: That is the FIRE dogma, mate. It is that index fund life.

Andy: Yes. As I say, in my opinion, it is the second best way that you can invest your money. Is anyone going to turn around, throw their hands up in the air and be miserable as a result of it? I cannot foresee a scenario. It is a fantastic way to go about it.

About Andy's Business

Captain FI: Speaking of fantastic value, give us a plug for the business, mate. Tell us a bit about what you do, the services you provide, and what services you could offer to the FIRE community or someone on the path to financial independence.

Andy: Independent Wealth Advice, based in Sydney, with an office in Martin Place. By virtue of technology, I would love to say I have a client in every state, but I do not have anyone in the Northern Territory, and I am almost considering running some Facebook ads there just so I can say that. I like to think I am a little bit different in the sense that it is not an ongoing fee piece with us. It is more about getting people set up, and if people want to meet with me on an ongoing basis, or they do have something going on that they need to see me regularly for, you just pay an hourly rate, or an agreed amount of hourly time. That is one thing I do quite differently, which I think is a bit of a no-brainer, to be honest. [Editor: this has changed since recording.]

Outside of that, I also pride myself on having a solution for anyone. I have dealt with clients well north of multiple, multiple millions in investments, north of five, and equally we have a lot of people who are quite everyday Australians. With me, if I see someone and they are already in a good super fund and already pretty much structured correctly, my little line I always say is, good for you, bad for me. My perfect client is someone who is in a retail fund or a poor bank fund, or paying advisor fees, and they come and see me and basically say, look, so-and-so is such a nice person and they have this beautiful office that overlooks the harbour or the river or whatever, and they seem really nice, but I cannot quite figure out why I am paying this person thousands a year or tens of thousands a year. And I say, yes, because I am sorry to tell you, but you are actually not getting good value.

I spend a lot of time and money trying to make the website as interactive as possible, so it tries to outline whether you are going to be a good client. It is a very simple process. Drop me an email, drop me a call, or book in via the little booking thing on iwadvice.com.au. [...] The point is that I really do pride myself on the fact that it is not just a default where everyone goes into the same cookie-cutter advice of conflicted products. It is about doing things right for people. I also spend a lot of time, sometimes a little bit too much time, blogging about things that I think are interesting, and I am personally very interested in fees. If you are, check out the blog from time to time, because there are plenty of examples of specific companies that I write about, and some of those companies are not particularly enthused about that. By all means subscribe to the blog or the newsletter, and hopefully, if you do not need advice, you can at least get an entertaining update and keep abreast of change.

Captain FI: Awesome stuff, mate. I will make sure we include all of those links in the show notes. If you are listening and you want to head over and check out Andy's site and his business, jump onto the blog and scroll down to the bottom. There will be links to Andy's website and some of the entertaining blog posts that he has written recently, which just stirred up the hornets' nest. Always good to see people poking the bear. Andy, mate, again, thanks so much for your time and your experience. You are obviously a wealth of knowledge. I personally really appreciate what you are doing. You are not out there to rip people off. So good on you, man, and I really hope the business model works for you. If anyone has been thinking about getting some advice, hit him up. He will be honest enough to tell you whether it is actually going to be worth it or not.

Andy: A hundred percent. Thanks for having me. I am a big fan of the podcast and the blog, and I love financial advice. I love talking about it, so it is a pleasure.

Captain FI: Mate, it has been awesome. Enjoy the rest of your Sunday.

Andy: Thanks so much. Appreciate it. Just one piece of housekeeping: all the information we discussed in this podcast is just factual information and at most general advice. What that means is it does not take into account your specific needs or circumstances, so you need to consider your own financial position, objectives and requirements before making any decisions, and ideally you should seek financial advice. Independent Wealth Advice is a corporate authorised representative, and I, Andrew Darroch, am a registered financial advisor as well. [Editor: this has changed since recording.]

Book A Consultation

If you do not need advice, you find out for $330, not $6,600.

  • 45 minutes with the adviser himself, not a junior
  • A fixed quote on the call, if advice is warranted
  • The $330 is credited in full if you proceed

Why $330 and not free? A free first meeting is usually paid for later, through ongoing fees. I would rather you paid once for my time and owed me nothing.

Book A $330 Consultation

Pay $330 now. A consultation, not an advice session. Reschedule up to 48 hours before.