Skip To Content

Four consultations a week. Book It

Podcast Transcript

Aussie Firebug: Why Financial Advice Is Mostly Sales

The host of the Aussie Firebug podcast interviewed me in 2025. We cover sales versus advice, what independent means, ongoing fees, industry funds and AI.

Key Points

  • Andy says the advice industry in Australia is 99% sales and 1% advice, and puts it down to incentives.
  • He describes ongoing percentage fees as one of the most lucrative business models in human history, because the work does not rise with the balance.
  • He argues advice should be paid for when it is needed, the way you pay a doctor, a lawyer or a plumber, rather than through a retainer.
  • He explains that independence is a regulated term and says he believes only one or two percent of advisers in the country are independent.
  • He says he cannot design a better portfolio than a top-flight industry fund, and that passive ETFs are the second best investment.
  • He says the cost of advice is a problem, but that the perception of being sold to is a big reason people avoid advisers.
  • He says the one place he would encourage FIRE investors to look beyond passive investing is a high-quality industry fund within super.

Why Andy Became An Adviser

Host: Today we are joined by independent financial advisor Andy Darroch. Welcome to the show, Andy.

Andy: Thanks. Glad to be here.

Host: How about we start off with a little bit about yourself, what you do, and how you found yourself in the industry that you are in at the moment?

Andy: A real guilty pleasure of mine is listening to podcasts with financial advisors on them. I love it when they sing this big sonnet about how they got into advice to help people, and all this very self-indulgent [nonsense].

I grew up in country Queensland. I came from a family of accountants, so I went to study accounting. I pretty quickly realised that accounting was not for me, and a pretty logical way out of that is financial advice.

I was really fortunate. I got to work at what I consider some really prestigious institutions, like Macquarie Private Bank and what was one of Australia's oldest stockbroking firms, Wilson HTM. But I pretty quickly formed the opinion that if you are cursed with objective thought and independent assessment, it does not take too long before you realise that the advice industry at large prioritises fees over people.

So for that reason, in 2021, I set up my own business, Independent Wealth Advice, and the idea behind that was no ongoing fees, exclusively using industry funds and passive ETFs. Then just recently we have launched a new part of the business, which is called Honest Advice, or the Honest Advisor, which is the natural evolution of that. Again, it seeks to provide low-cost, one-off advice that just centres on industry funds and ETFs. [Editor: this has changed since recording.]

Host: There is a couple of associations, obviously. Even with all the changes that happened, there was a huge royal commission that went through your industry in 2016 or something, was it?

Andy: Yes, 2017, 2018. Prior to that there was the Future of Financial Advice reforms. There has been a bunch of reviews and inquiries. It is an industry that is not a stranger to inquiries, for good reason.

Host: It has always puzzled me, and I am not an expert, but even after the commission, my understanding is that financial advisors were still able to get kickbacks from insurance products.

Andy: I would not say that the royal commission changed a great deal. One of the biggest takeouts from it is that the banks at large sold off their businesses, but I would not say that the behaviours of those businesses has changed. If you asked me what the current landscape of the financial advice industry is, I would say it is broadly similar to what it was 10 years ago, and 10 years before that. And I would say it is completely broken. It is borderline useless.

Sales Versus Advice

Andy: What do people actually want when they go to see a financial advisor? I will give you a hint. It is in the name and it begins with an A. They want advice. But what do they get instead? They get sales. They get sold. I think it is not ridiculous to say that the advice industry in Australia is 99% sales and 1% advice. I think everyone would do themselves a service if they replaced the word advisor or planner, or whatever increasingly ridiculous terms the industry is using, with what is essentially a financial planner with a salesperson. Because that is what the industry is there to do. It is there to sell financial products to people.

Why is it perennially broken? You can boil it down to a really simple fact, and I love that Charlie Munger line: show me the incentive and I will show you the outcome. If you have got a financial advisor, they have the opportunity to charge ongoing fees. That might come in the form of insurance commissions, or it might be literally charging a fee on your portfolio. That happens to be one of the most lucrative business models in human history.

At its core, financial advice is really just the ugly cousin of investment management. What makes it so lucrative is that you are not actually doing a tremendous amount of work. If your advisor is charging you 1% and managing a portfolio of $2 million, is that four times the work of a $500,000 portfolio? I would say it is absolutely not.

There have been surface-level changes. A prime example of the takeout from the royal commission is that the banks were forcefully encouraged to get rid of their wealth operations. A big problem was vertical integration, whereby I walk into bank A and I end up in a bank A insurance product, a bank A investment product, bank A debt, and so on. Broadly speaking, that has not got good results for people, because the bank is obliged to prioritise shareholders, not customers. It is not to say that everyone got absolutely ruined, but I will bet you my left hand that they got the second or third best solution that was available. And a 1% difference in returns over a 30-year period is 20% of the balance. This stuff makes massive differences long term.

Going back to the advice industry as a whole, I would say it is seriously ineffectual at what it sets out to do, which is provide advice, because it is legitimately just all sales. The reason is simple. It is such a lucrative business model that if you say to an advisor, instead of telling this million-dollar client they are going to pay you 10 grand a year, I want you to work with them once for a one-off fee of $2,000 or $3,000 or maybe more, and then move on to the next, that advisor is probably going to laugh in your face and say, why [on earth] would I do that, when I can just follow the industry standard model, which is stuff people into managed funds and things that look and smell like that, and charge an ongoing retainer for not doing a tremendous amount of work.

This is a multi-billion dollar industry. It is perceived as being very complicated and it can be. I love that line, a wealth of information creates a poverty of attention. If I phrase it more colourfully, I would say, if you cannot dazzle them with brilliance, baffle them with [nonsense]. There are 40,000 plus different investment options for your super, so it is easy for people to get overwhelmed and then go down the path of getting an advisor. But the problem is that the industry routinely prioritises sales over actual advice.

Host: I really want to hammer home this idea of sales versus advice, because it has been brought up before. I have had advisors on before, Phil Harvey being the most recent one, and Phil really spoke about that. I want to make sure people out there understand exactly what you mean. I go to see a financial advisor. What is the difference between that advisor giving me advice versus selling me something?

Andy: Unfortunately for everyone, the only real purpose of a financial advisor is to sell stuff. You might say that we give tax advice, and we do. We are supposed to be the specialists with superannuation, but superannuation is not that difficult. There are many accountants that can handle it. At its core, advice is a sales industry. People might get their back up when I say that, but in essence, pharmacists are the same. You do not have to take it as an insult. You have a problem and you get sold a product that provides a solution to it.

If you go and see an advisor, my opinion is that the absolute best thing you can get out of that is winding up in an industry fund that does not pay ongoing fees, a low-cost ETF portfolio that does not pay ongoing fees, and ideally some insurance arrangements that do not pay commissions. But the advisor is not incentivised to do that, because you are tossing up a really lucrative ongoing income stream, or a one-off piece of advice where you are selling yourself out of a job. So it is unbelievably hard to find an advisor that provides advice as opposed to sales.

There are, I do not know, 16,000 advisors in the country. I could count on one hand the ones that I know personally that follow the same kind of advice model we do. My philosophy is that we should all pay for advice the way you pay a doctor, a lawyer or a plumber. You pay them when you need assistance. If you get good advice, the advisor will not be a necessary part of that process for at least nine out of 10 people. If you get set up in the right super fund from the get-go, what is the likelihood that you need to change that within a decade? It is incredibly low. Similarly, if you are set up in a low-cost, well-designed, set and forget ETF portfolio, why do you need to get it checked up every year when the advice is always going to be to leave it alone? I love that Bogle thing, that the less you log into your investment account, the more you retire with at the end.

If I get a will done, do I pay a lawyer a monthly retainer? No. If my situation changes, I will go and get it reviewed, or if it has been five or ten years and the law might be different. But I do not go unless there is a need to. If I buy a house off a real estate agent, do I pay them a trailing commission? No. If someone sells me a car, do I pay them a trailing commission? No, because they sold me the product that fits what I need. Your superannuation should not be like a car or a house, it should last your entire life. You might change what is under the bonnet, if I can use that analogy. You might update the investment options as you get closer to retirement, because broadly speaking people can take a lot more risk earlier in life compared to later in life. Advice can be really helpful, but it is not the annual obligation that the industry purports it to be. That boils down to incentives, because it is so ludicrously profitable and in the interest of the advisor.

Why Ongoing Fees Persist

Host: How does a financial advisor benefit from selling a specific product? I thought that was ruled out.

Andy: It is less the product and more the fees around the product. This is the traditional advice model. I am Joe Blogs and I have got a million dollars to invest, spread across my super and my personal cash. I go and see an advisor and they will say, we have got this magic portfolio of managed funds, you should pay us 1% to choose those funds for you and watch your money grow. They do not get kickbacks from the managed funds themselves. Once upon a time they did, but not since I joined the industry, and I have been doing this for 11 or 12 years. Back in the day they certainly did.

Then there are more imperceptible ways that an advice firm is influenced. Broadly speaking the banks do not really own advice arms anymore, but you tend to find that there are companies affiliated with the advice firm, and you would very commonly find you are in an investment product that is sold and manufactured by that business. That is what we typically call a wrap account, which in simple terms is like a super fund. It is not to say they are getting kickbacks, but the business would price it so effectively that the advisor could easily sell it. Generally the advisor has to say two things to you: A, this is how the advice is going to leave you in a better position, and B, we have considered other things, we have not just cookie-cutter put you into this one thing. Now, I only have to consider two other products, so it is ridiculously easy for me to find two [poor] products that are more expensive than the one I am recommending, and that may or may not be affiliated with me.

Whenever you provide advice you have to do it in what has got to be the most monotonous creation in human history, which is called a Statement of Advice. These things are written in jargon and legalese, and you can bury anything in terminology. It is very subjective. You could say, the benefit of moving from this industry fund to our managed portfolio is X, Y and Z. If you know the industry quite well, you might say your assumptions on X, Y and Z are bogus. But if you write it in the right way, it is completely compliant. The normal person is not going to know, especially if they are coming to you for financial advice because they do not know anything about investing or money.

Find me a single big firm that does advice the way we do it. It sounds infuriatingly self-indulgent, but it is really hard to find an advice firm that provides one-off advice, compared to the legal profession, the accounting profession or the medical profession, where that is just synonymous. You have a need to get it sorted out, versus it really is a sales game.

Where you have got this really lucrative path on one side, and the whole industry subscribes to it, there is an entire industry built around the advice industry, which is multi-billion dollar. And the advice industry itself has been doing this for over 10 years, and some of my closest friends work in it. I have a lot to lose by being what I describe as a self-hating financial advisor. People fall prey to being in a thought bubble or groupthink, because you do get quite a delusional perception of the competitors, which is broadly low-cost ETFs and industry funds. If someone's pay cheque depends on something, you are going to have a hard time convincing them otherwise, because they are so biased. It is not always sinister. It is that they have always existed in this echo chamber of, no, no, no, industry funds, we can beat the market, we help clients ongoing. And you go, well, no, it is simply not the case.

Host: So really it is the trailing fees. A lot of people probably listening to this podcast have parents who have got a bit older, and they have started looking into how they have been set up. So many people get put in these weird, hard-to-leave investment options, and you do think, did this advisor put my friend or family member in here to make it very hard for them to leave me and the firm?

Andy: I think it is ignorance in the majority of cases, as opposed to maniacal brilliance. Look, some might. There are 16,000 of them, all kept on a register. I like to joke there are only two kinds of people that I know that are kept on public registers, and I will let you deduce from that what you will.

One thing I will correct is that commission is a very incendiary word in the advice space, and I am not referring to commissions here. Commission is bad because it is paid by the product, so if someone pays me a higher commission, I am going to flog their product. Versus the management fee, or what I call ongoing advice fees paid by the client. The industry standard for these is 1%, and if you take 1% over 30 years, there is 20% of your balance gone.

If advisors could deliver the best product, I would be fine. I say to every one of my clients, if I could design a better investment portfolio than a big industry fund, fees [aside], every person I have ever met would be in it. But I cannot. Without sounding insufferably arrogant, I consider myself very good at what I do. But I cannot design a better investment portfolio than a top-flight industry fund, because I do not have the resources, the scale, the fee bargaining, or hundreds of analysts doing my work for me. If I cannot, I have no faith that any other advisor can. That is why I started my own business in 2021, because I got no satisfaction from sitting in front of people at the end of the year and seeing the quite enormous amount of fees they paid.

When someone first sees you, there is all this information out there, the news, online, everything else, and they just need someone to distil it all and put them on the right path. But from then onwards, it is pure profit and clipping the ticket, as we call it in the industry. If you take a different approach and set people up in the right products at the start, which for me is always industry funds and low-cost ETFs, then they do not need to pay for advice going forward, because I am not pretending to manage it. I have worked at some of the best trading floors in the country. There is not a financial investment product that I have not seen or been able to work out how it works. I have never seen a better portfolio than an industry fund, for the simple fact that anyone trying to compete with them is in a completely different league. You could have a quite similar argument for passive ETFs, which I would say are the second best investment any human being can possess. They are so low fee, so well diversified, there is so much literature supporting them, they are low tax, they tick all the boxes. The problem is, they do not pay me anything to sell them.

Host: There is very little difference in managing a portfolio of $300,000 versus $15 million if it is all in the same ETF. Is that right?

Andy: Here is the problem. Say I see a client with a decent amount of money in their personal name and a decent amount in their super. If I say to them, I want you to go into industry funds A and B and diversified ETFs A and B, and by the way, because I am such a genius and such a nice guy, you are going to pay me one percent, and they say sounds great. After a year, nothing will have changed. Their investment options will not be any different. Hopefully it has gone up. Then the second year goes by and nothing changes. Sooner or later the client is going to say, you have got this lovely view of the harbour, but why are we paying you 1% of our portfolio when nothing is ever changing? The money is being managed by ETF provider A or industry fund B. I would say, yes, they manage it because they can do it better than I can, and they would say, so why are we paying you 1%? Because I am a middleman. That is not going to fly long term.

What tends to happen is that a wrap platform has to be managed by an advisor. Generally speaking, they create a situation that is complicated and requires their assistance. It is that old line, you are treating the symptoms, not the cure. The person comes to you and says, we want to invest money. You can cure that problem by giving them off-the-shelf, set and forget solutions, or you can treat the symptoms and lock yourself into an ongoing process, where I say, we have got the approach for you, we will put you in this portfolio of managed funds and stocks and ETFs. It is not that I am getting commissions from those products. It is more that the client looks at it and goes, what is this jumble of digits, I have no idea. In essence it is actually quite simple, but you need the advisor to translate it. Sometimes they will deliberately give you an option that they know you will need them to continue with. Not sometimes, I would say 99-point-something percent of the time. I do not think it is always that someone looks at a client and thinks they are a big bag of money. I think the industry has been doing it like this for so long that they cannot understand there are better ways to do it, because that would involve realising that at their core they are middlemen, and you can do yourself out of a job.

I like to say the advice industry is like VCR salespeople, except it is not the 90s anymore. It is 2025 and I can stream everything. They are still out there flogging VCRs. Even 30 years ago you could argue that ETFs were nascent in the States, let alone existing here. We did not have all these wonderful things that have basically done people out of a job in my industry, because they do what we do better. There is still the need for advice. You still need someone to set you up. The problem is, good luck finding someone who does it in what I consider an honest fashion.

What Independent Actually Means

Host: You are an independent financial advisor. Are there legal definitions around an independent financial advisor in Australia, and if so, what exactly are they?

Andy: Yes, there is. [...] In essence it is a combination of three things. A, that you do not work for or are part-owned by a product manufacturer, which might be a big bank or someone else manufacturing products. B, you have to have what we call an open APL. An APL is an approved product list. Most financial advisors will have a list of things they can choose from, whether that is managed funds, insurance policies or ETFs. That is put there for good reason, so that you do not go and see financial planner A in city B and they start flogging you their uncle's unlisted property fund. That is there for the right intent, but it means that someone might not be able to recommend a product that is not on the list.

Third, probably the biggest impediment for most people, is insurance commission. If you are independent, you cannot receive any kind of volume-based payment, which refers to insurance commission. I do not know the exact statistics, but I think it would be fair to say maybe one or two percent of advisors in the country are independent. I would say any advisor could still give good advice if they were not independent, but the economic incentive is not there to do it.

When I set up my own business, a mandatory thing I wanted was the ability to recommend any fund I wanted, and that led me to being independent. For me independence is really important, and it is a regulated term. If you do not satisfy those criteria, you cannot represent yourself to be independent. That does not stop advisors from all firms and businesses doing it, in my opinion, but it is a regulated term.

But independence is only half the battle. Someone might be independent and still put you into something broadly similar to what we just discussed, which is a wrap account with a bunch of boring, stodgy, third-grade managed funds, where you are haemorrhaging something akin to one percent of your balance a year. I do not think the advice industry sets out to do harm. I think what it does is set out to charge fees as priority number one, and that essentially transfers money from the client to yourself, because all the money wasted in ongoing fees could be going back into the portfolio and compounding over the longer term.

Host: Someone emailed me that there are less than 10 financial advisors, maybe, in your state, New South Wales, who are independent. It sounds crazy.

Andy: It is entirely possible. I think there are a couple of hundred. There are two organisations which represent independent advisors, CIFAA and PIFA. Of those there would be fewer than a hundred members, and I think there would be probably a hundred kicking around that are not associated with either association. Independence is important, and it is the first word in my business for a reason. But independence creates the impression that your interests are aligned with the client, that you are not pushing an agenda for a bank. We have gone from that being a major problem, particularly with commissions pre-GFC and pre-royal commission, to the problem now being very much ongoing fees, and independence does not insulate a person from that. If you take two examples, one client follows a traditional advice method and the other goes into low-cost industry funds and low-cost ETFs, I bet you my left hand that the latter will end up with a significantly higher investment balance.

Why More Advisers Do Not Work This Way

Host: Here is the million dollar question, Andy. If your method of providing financial advice is so much better, why are there not more advisors doing it? And why are people not choosing to pay a higher upfront cost versus the ongoing management fees?

Andy: It is genuinely really hard to find. If you find me many more advisors running it the way we do it, let me know, because I will probably try to hide them. First, people do not fully understand how dislocated the industry is from their objectives and interests. Second, why do not more people do it? Because it is an incredibly arduous way to run a business. You are constantly fending for new clients. The costs of running an advice business are high. We are a really strongly regulated industry, and I think that is for really good reason. For all the people crying out for deregulation in the financial services industry, I probably do not share their opinion. But why do not more people do it? Because it is a [real] slog. It is much less glamorous. It is substantially less profitable.

When I set up this business I chatted to some consultants, and I found it hilarious that they said, no, no, your business model is wrong, you have got to be doing this. And I was like, I can do mathematics. I understand that. It is a foreign concept within the industry. The number one thing is that it is just not as profitable. As to why people do not seek it out, I think people are not as aware of what they should be asking for, because we have this big group think where the entire industry does not rate it as an option.

We have to shift out of this mentality of fees onto clients. Instead of having a cushy book of 50 or 60 people who pay you a retainer, where you do not do a lot, you jumble around a couple of managed funds, and I would argue you act as a glorified middleman, we go to a profession that is more similar to a lawyer, where some clients you see regularly, someone might be super complicated, and a vast majority of people you fix at the start and then potentially never see again. Or maybe you see them 10 years later and you say, yep, everything is fine, here is your gold stamp, go and enjoy your life. I think change will have to come from outside the industry, and that will come from education. It starts slow and builds pretty quickly. There is a greater and greater share of people who are engaged. But a lot of the financial podcasts you hear are really just pushing the age-old agenda: insurance associated with commissions, and ongoing fees, which I would argue are completely a waste of money.

The Traditional Adviser's Case

Host: Put yourself in a traditional advisor's shoes. What would they say is better for the client, the way they do it versus the way you do it?

Andy: I have heard it a million times and it is always one of two delusions. One is that industry funds are these ridiculous investments that do not actually make the returns they make, which is a complete load of garbage. It is a tired old conspiracy that has never eventuated. And if their premise were correct, then you would go to passive instruments, and that would not be an issue.

I would liken this to a car. You are in the market for a new car and you can buy any car in the world, any make or model, or you can go to your local mechanic and they say, I will design a car just for you, Andy, because you are such a great guy. Who is the better placed to design a car? My local mechanic, who is a great guy, or a multi-billion dollar car company with decades of experience, thousands of engineers, and resources my local mechanic could not even dream of? And who is incentivised? The mechanic might not make any money if I go and buy a Toyota or a BMW. And secondly, I can still choose the make, the model and the colour. So any semblance that they can outperform a big industry fund is ludicrous. They are in a completely different league. They do not have access to as good investments. They have got higher costs. Others would say that industry funds are bad investments. I say, open your eyes and do some maths, because that is not the case. They are unbelievable. They are the greatest money-making machine ever conceived.

The second line that I hear constantly wheeled out, a lot on podcasts, is this notion of helping people achieve their goals and objectives and all this kind of rubbish. When you think about it, what does an advisor do at its core? They choose investments for you, and that might include the tax effects of those investments. Advice has typically been aimed at the wealthier end of the market, because if I am charging percentage-based fees I am going to do the same amount of work for a $100,000 client or a $3 million client, so who do I want to deal with? Generally speaking, older Australians and wealthier Australians do not really want budgeting advice. A lot of people say, we work with our clients and check in with them quarterly and annually and make sure their finances move with them. That is ridiculous, because if your super is changing every year, whoever put you in it is a goose, because it should not be. You should be in the same thing for really a decade. If you are under 40, take more risk, and the closer you get to 60, ratchet down that risk. That is a once-a-decade discussion.

Similarly, for people investing money in their personal name, it is really two choices. Do you need to access this in the next couple of years? If yes, probably do not put it in stocks, because you might start with $100,000 and have $80,000 through no one's fault, just because of the market. If someone is longer term, we say, excellent, here is the best ETF for you, here is whose name we want it in and why, and here are some things we might be able to do tax-wise so less of that return is surrendered in taxes and fees. Then it is set and forget. The notion that I have got to check in with them all the time is ridiculous.

For people who say, we are here to calm people's nerves, well, what is the answer every time something blows up? Credit Suisse is going under, oh my god, what should I do with my super? Nothing. There is all this tariff discussion and geopolitical tension in the world. What should I do with my investments in super? Nothing. You have to be in the right investment at the get-go. If someone in their 60s had all their money in international stocks, that is probably not right. They should be in something like balanced. But once you are in the right product at the start, there should not be a tremendous amount of ongoing work. There are circumstances where someone has really complicated affairs and it might take a year to untangle all the accounts. Outside of that, once you are in them, just let them go. If you want to pay for a review, you should do it the way you do medical advice, legal advice, virtually every kind of professional advice, where you pay an hourly fee if you need it. [Editor: this has changed since recording.]

If you are a hypochondriac and you go and see your doctor once a fortnight for every new freckle or tickle, that is your right, as long as your doctor is cool with it. The advice industry automatically defaults everyone into being that hypochondriac, who has to see us. The problem is that because I put someone in a portfolio of managed funds with a wrap, it is really hard to dislocate from the advisor. They cannot just sack me and have it be set and forget. I would not even necessarily say it is evil intent. I think it is more that everyone does it because everyone does it. If I put someone in an industry fund and they want to call me once a week to chat about markets, I love talking about stocks, go for your life, but you are not going to make any money out of it, and almost no one does.

Is Upfront Advice More Expensive?

Host: A common criticism I have heard, and tell me if I am wrong, is that the way you do it, the independent way, is a lot more expensive upfront, because you charge by the hour, whereas the traditional way is not as expensive upfront, but it shows up over many years. Is that true?

Andy: No, it is not. Find me someone who parrots that line, and I will bet you my left hand they have a financial incentive to regurgitate that. It is not even necessarily more expensive upfront. We have two businesses now. We have one that aims to do lower-cost advice via workshops, which for a vast majority of people is all they need. [Editor: this has changed since recording.] Everyone has to produce a Statement of Advice. If I say to Mr and Mrs Klein, I want you to go into these funds for these reasons, I am obliged to produce a Statement of Advice. That is for good intent. It is to disclose the fees and the associations. That has noble intent, but it ends up being an administrative hurdle that does not really change any of the behaviours. It creates a bunch of paperwork and you all get to the same destination, which is wrap products paying ongoing fees.

Is it more expensive upfront? No. I have not seen any evidence to suggest that at all. The FAAA, the association for advisors, puts out estimates on costs. I have seen companies that charge 8 or 10 grand for an SOA and then want ongoing fees, and some people might not charge for an SOA, but charge ongoing fees. It is absolutely not true.

Host: So the Statement of Advice, I think either way you slice it they are going to have to charge. Where I come to you, by law you are required to give me a Statement of Advice before you do anything. I go to a traditional advisor, same sort of thing. It might cost anywhere between three and a half and five thousand, and it goes up to 10, which is insane.

Andy: We do Statements of Advice. We started at three and it is up to over four now. [Editor: this has changed since recording.] But it is not all ASIC's fault. ASIC are demonised by the industry. They are trying to prevent people putting out advice, going carte blanche and just selling things.

Host: I do want to talk about the regulatory hurdles that ASIC have introduced later on. But right now, both methods charge for the Statement of Advice. What about after that? A year goes by. It is the second year. I have a hundred thousand. I will play devil's advocate and go to the lower end. With the traditional method I can check in with my advisor multiple times a year and it is covered within that management fee. Whereas if I go to you and I need advice, or I want that sleep-at-night factor, I want to speak to you, we are emotional human beings, is that a per-hour fee on your model? Could there be an argument that in that situation, with a low balance, the traditional model actually works out cheaper?

Andy: No. For the following reasons. A single advisor that is going to deal with the $100,000 client who is not the kid of one of their big clients, that just does not happen. B, they are going to charge you an upfront SOA fee, and advisors have free rein to charge however they want. Then a wrap product: depending on what they put you in, you will be spending a significant amount of money in administration fees and then in investment fees on the managed funds or ETFs they recommend, because 100 grand is not enough to do a decent stock portfolio. And then three, you will be paying advice fees. So it is not just the advice fee. It is also the things around it, which include higher administration costs and higher investment management fees.

If someone is ultra nervous and needs to constantly check in, I have had clients like that, and there are ETF providers that have hotlines where you can speak to someone who is skilled in general advice. They are getting better and better at putting out market updates and podcasts and FAQ guides. I always say to people, you can pay me 300 bucks an hour to hear my take on Credit Suisse blowing themselves up. [Editor: this has changed since recording.] It does not matter. Or whatever is coming around the corner, who knows what will be next, a crypto event that triggers a bond crisis. No one knows, that is the whole point. But I will bet you the CIO or head honcho of your ETF or super fund is on a podcast, or when you log into your account they will have half-yearly or annual investment updates. For that nervous person, they could log on to any number of YouTube channels, podcasts or direct websites and get updates. Repetition is an effective way of education. Someone might need that in the first year, then a fifth of that the year after, and by the third year they might be cured. They might go, I understand now, stocks go up, stocks go down, that is why I am in this style of investment. But by the time they do not need it in the third or fourth or fifth year, they are chained in this [poor] product. If it is in their personal name, it might have tax consequences for moving. These things are terrible to manage without advisors. In many ways you are handcuffed. That is why it is so unbelievably profitable. So either way you slice it, it is more expensive. One hundred percent.

How The Industry Got Here

Host: Let us zoom out a bit. How do we get here, in your opinion, Andy, and what do we do to fix it?

Andy: We got here in a number of ways. It is not just incentives. In the 1980s you could not just go and buy something that gave you broad exposure to the entire stock market. You could not use online brokers. Technology has changed the game. Investing in 2025 is a completely different beast to even 2015, and 2015 is a different age compared to the 90s. Before the advent and proliferation of ETFs, the only way to get broad exposure to the market, which is what everyone should seek to do, because the only free lunch you get in this game is diversification, was through managed funds, and financial advisors were the gatekeepers of those. Not by malicious intent. That is just what they did. They sold managed funds. And what they have been selling, like VCRs, was red hot in the 90s. VCRs are great for watching Toy Story on. But suddenly they are not as crash hot anymore, and there is way better stuff out there, but my whole business is predicated on it.

The other way is incentives. The industry traditionally made money from stockbroking in the 80s and then transitioned into more sales of managed funds in the 90s. It has had a very common tune to it, which is that there were a lot of commissions generated. In the 90s an advisor, or insurance salesman as they are commonly referred to, might not have charged you ongoing fees, but there was ongoing commission. I sell someone fund A and I get a trailing commission on that. That does not happen in Australia now. Because that was outlawed, people transitioned to, we have got to keep money coming through the door. That is what a business thrives on, and it is a [lot] easier to keep selling the same clients stuff as opposed to constantly finding new ones. It is kind of a lack of ambition. The environment has created this cushy environment where advisors have this really lucrative business model, and there has not really been any need to disrupt it. I am sure some tried, but no one has really caught on, because the advice industry is dominated by that.

Host: I do not know if you read this, but there was a report from ASIC, titled something like Financial Advice: What Consumers Really Think. It found that 49% of the people who were surveyed did not get advice because they thought advisors were more interested in making money for themselves. I thought that was an incredible data point, because if the end goal is to get people quality financial advice, especially at a time of their life when they need it the most, which is probably younger people, in their late 20s, 30s and 40s, when they are having kids and making huge financial decisions about where to put their super, what house to buy and how to structure their finances, how is it that we seem to be going backwards? They keep regulating and the end result seems worse.

Andy: There is a lot to unpack there. The first point is that if you go and see an advisor, I do not think you are going to get a good deal, but you are not going to blow yourself up. You are probably going to be reasonably well invested, you are going to be insured, and you are going to be conscious of taxes and super. The problem is you are not going to be in the best investments. At the very best you are going to be in the second best, because you cannot be in an industry fund or a low-cost ETF. Second to that, you are going to haemorrhage a ton of money in fees, which is not going to leave you broke, but it is probably going to mean that you retire with less money than you could have.

Host: That is so important for people to understand. This is a FIRE podcast, so it is very much an audience that understands finances and investing, and we are being picky a little bit. It is tens of thousands of dollars difference, maybe even hundreds of thousands. But it is still better than someone who never got financial advice at all, if the barrier to entry is so high. For someone who is 28 and about to start a family, to drop three and a half to five thousand dollars on a Statement of Advice is out of their means, so they never go down the path of investing.

Andy: Probably not would be my answer, because if you are one of the millions of people by default in an industry fund and you go and see an advisor, they will conjure up a reason to get you out of it, which is based in fantasy in my mind. If you had not gone to see that advisor, you might have stayed in a better investment. A one percent difference in returns over 30 years is 20 percent of your balance. That could mean retiring with 800 grand as opposed to a million. And that is just saying you get the same return and you just paid 1% to an advisor, which I would argue is not the case. So broadly speaking you should hope that people end up better as a result of advice, but it depends on your starting point. You might already, by default, be in a ridiculously good industry fund, and you just needed someone to say, hey, you are 28, go high growth.

Historically the whole notion that there are all these barriers to entry is not untrue, but it is a surrogate of the way advisors make money. There are broadly speaking two different business models in advice: I am an insurance jockey, or I am your more traditional financial planner flogging managed funds. People with high investment balances closer to retirement, particularly in super, are where most firms have focused, because that is where the high balances are. If you say to someone, we will manage your super, but they have got $60,000, it is not worthwhile for the advisor, because there is a fixed cost component to keeping the lights on and the systems running. Australia is in many ways a utopia in finance. I know a lot of what I say is quite pessimistic, but this is a country where the investment opportunity is the greatest on the planet that I have seen.

Insurance Commissions

Andy: The way the industry has traditionally made money off younger people is the insurance route. I have always worked in stockbroking firms, so I have never done a huge amount of it prior to starting my own business. It is without a doubt regarded as the less glamorous and bit shady end of the industry. If I say to you insurance salesman, I am sure you are not thinking of a refined gentleman with a monocle and an English accent. You probably think of some beaten-up bloke.

The problem with insurance is that you still get commissions there. That is not great, but it means the client does not get the sticker shock. They do not see us charging five grand for advice. They just see, we are going to sell you a $10,000 insurance policy, which might pay X percent to the advisor. The other problem is that human beings are more motivated to avoid disaster than seek out gain, so using fear as sales is incredibly effective. Similar to a lot of parts of the industry, I do not think anyone has cracked a book and looked at the statistics, because when you look at insurance sales, you invariably see advisors come up with garbage statistics about the likelihood of calamity and exacerbating the claim rates. When you look at the claim rates, it is less than a percent for Australians broadly. What is more noxious than that is the cancellation rates. Picking one at random, look at life insurance sold through financial advisors: 22.2% of policies are cancelled within a year. If you have got cancellation rates in double digits, to me that implies a culture of overselling. That is why the insurance commissions are weighted to the upfront, because the industry at large knows that cancellations happen and, by virtue of that, you want your fix first. The counter argument is that I am going to need less life insurance in five years than I need today, and that is completely true. But I cannot tell you how prevalent over-insurance is through advisor channels, and the basis for that is the remuneration structure.

Host: Have you seen that personally, that the clients you are servicing are older and wealthier, when the younger ones are probably the ones who need it?

Andy: Definitely. But there is less you can do for someone at a younger age. There are three points in your life where it is worth getting advice. Early in life, sort out your super and get the right investments, and for those it is important to, such as new parents, get your insurance sorted. It is also really easy to do. It is just really hard to find someone who will do that for you at a fair price and actually give you what I would say is good advice. The second time is the closer you get to retirement, because a lot of people do not have a good understanding of how it works practically, and a lot of what you do is tidying things up and demystifying it, which is not rocket surgery. And thirdly, the other impetus for getting advice is if you have had a significant windfall, whether that is selling a business, a lottery win or an inheritance. You have got this big stack of money and you would rather pay an expert to make sure you do not get yourself into hot water.

Regulation, The Best Interest Duty And Paperwork

Andy: It is legislated to do the best interest duty. The best interest duty says that I am going to do what is best for my client. But to substantiate that, I just have to have a reason. There are a bajillion different reasons for me to recommend wrap product A or super fund X. I could say they do this thing, which the client does not care about, and I know they do not care about, but if it is in the Statement of Advice, it ticks that box. I actually think ASIC does a really good job of regulating advice. The problem is that they can only write so many laws, and for every law you write, it is another couple of pages and a way around it.

Host: Let us say a $5,000 Statement of Advice. What percentage of that is to keep ASIC happy?

Andy: It depends. Probably the biggest drain on time is doing all the due diligence. If someone comes to see me, we have to get all the facts of their existing products. If someone has two or three super funds, we have to get the statements, and check whether there are capital gains problems, and whether this person has health conditions that mean we cannot just go gung-ho with the insurance. You need the full picture. If I say, that super fund is rubbish, it is gone, and then I find out they made contributions and we cannot claim a tax deduction for those, or there was a capital gain that no one thought to check, maybe that might have stopped us making the change. It is unlikely, but it is possible. Or this person has a health condition and I took them out of that fund, and they had insurance in their previous one, and now they are uninsurable. That is an issue. So a lot of it is basic diligence, through the regulatory prism if you want to call it that.

It is also generating a lot of further pressure from lobbying associated with the industry. They are calling it the great tsunami, that we have X million people due to retire in the next few years and we need more advisors. I would say no, I think we have got enough. They just need to focus their time, instead of overcharging a select bunch of the population, on servicing a large amount of the population. There are 16,000 plus advisors in Australia, and I would love to know how that compares to other industries, like physiotherapists or dentists.

The law is there for good reason. I hope we do not see massive changes to it. I think they are trying to loosen it a little to make it better for advice, and part of that is to allow super funds to provide advice, because most people do not need comprehensive advice. If you are already in a good super fund, you might walk in and say, what do I do? And it is literally just, how old are you? I am between 20 and 40. Excellent, put the turbocharger on your investment option. Get out of balance, which is the default for good reason, and go into growth or high growth. Then, what is your personal situation? Apply for these insurances and off you go.

Workshops And The Cost Barrier

Andy: The whole basis of our new business, Honest Advice, is to do workshops that go through that. Instead of charging one person five thousand bucks, we could do 20 or 30 at a time. That might not be everyone, but it is the lion's share of human beings who just need to know: these are the best super funds, these are the best ETFs, these are the tips and traps, and these are the insurances. It is not rocket surgery. [Editor: this has changed since recording.]

Host: I definitely agree. I just think it needs to be more flexible on price, because the price is such a barrier to entry for so many young people I speak to. I have people who have got financial advice and it is so expensive. You pay five and a half grand and what happens? You get the Statement of Advice, you do nothing, you do not act on it, it sits there gathering dust, and five years later, was that actually worth it? If I go to a boxing class, the instructor is not going to ask me for my medical records or get a complete health picture, and health is a lot more important than money. There is no law to say that the instructor of a fitness class needs to get your entire health picture. I think it is a bit insane that there is not an option to get very specific advice for a very specific situation without knowing the entire thing.

Andy: There are two things. I sound like a broken record, but 90% of it is profit. Why would I do 30 people at once for 500 bucks when I could get them to pay me potentially tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands of dollars a year in perpetuity? I do not have to work that hard. I sit in front of them every year and razzle-dazzle them with a bunch of jargon and say, we did broadly in line with equity market returns. The second, lesser but still present, impediment is risk. If I have 30 people in a room and I say, this thing is the worst, go to this, and someone in that room has a health condition and winds up uninsured, or someone has this awful capital gain that they get stung with, and I did not make it clear that was a possibility, or there is a disallowed deduction because I had not claimed a personal super contribution, which is not that hard to avoid, you just need a decent presentation. But there is the risk. Australia has extremely strong consumer protections in financial services, which is wonderful, and if someone makes a complaint they can take me to an ombudsman who will turn me inside out. That is part of the reason you see that good industry funds are not able to provide heaps of advice, because they have got millions of members and it is really hard for them to employ thousands or hundreds of advisors. That is one of the changes in the law that they are trying to make, which is sacrilege in the industry, and a major threat to my business model as well. But I think it is better for Australians as a whole, that you can call up your super fund and say, we are not going to ask where you had breakfast in 1997, but this is broad-brush stuff with your super. You can get that from a lot of podcasts, like ours and yours and others.

Regulation, Influencers And Public Demand

Host: I wanted to ask you about the ASIC guidelines for influencers.

Andy: Put yourself in ASIC's shoes. For every good egg there are a lot of baddies, and there is a lot of money to be made here. [...] I empathise with that. I am also a licensed advisor, so it is easy for me to sit here and say, too bad, so sad for everyone else. But I do empathise.

There is a culture in Australia, for better or worse, where a lot of Australians have this mindset that the government needs to save me. If someone gets swindled or ripped off, the government needs to step in, and now the 99% doing nothing wrong all have to take a hit, whether it is high compliance or licensing costs, because someone got ripped off. [...]

Host: All I am saying is I think the pendulum has swung too far in the regulatory area. I think it needs to come down, because eventually the cost of providing financial advice is too high, and that is backed up by the data points around young people, the people who need it most, not getting financial advice because it is too expensive.

Andy: That is not regulation that is causing that. That is the advice industry that is causing that. I do not disagree that the cost of advice is a problem. But it is not just the cost. A massive chunk of the reason people do not want to get advice is this perception that you are getting sold, and I think that perception is correct.

Host: I agree with you there. Really half of people do not go to a financial advisor because they think they are going to get ripped off, and that is a huge problem.

Andy: That is what 1% does to your balance. I get hate mail in online forums of all variety, and I find it quite funny, if I am honest. That is why I named the new part of our business Honest Advice. If you ask me what is the biggest thing missing in financial services in Australia, it is honesty. It is genuine trustworthiness, transparency and honesty. It does not have to be like that. For all the cynical takes on it and all the impediments, it is ludicrously easy to get on your best financial path in this country. It seriously is.

Host: Let us say you are the king of Australia for a year. What do you do to fix the advice industry?

Andy: I think it has got to come from a change in consumer demand. You have got to have more people knowing what to ask for. It is an educational point of view, and it takes time. I really do not think there is a way we are going to easily legislate our way out of this. Some of the changes that are proposed, and I do not know whether a changing government would preserve these or wind them back, such as the ability to get easy advice from your super fund, would probably do a world of good, because a lot of people could get advice on a singular issue. You could get that from an advisor, but they are not motivated to do it in this structure where they are charging ongoing fees. Their business is designed not to have people walk in the door and out and not see them again. It is designed to see them regularly.

I do not think I am the first person on earth who has ever offered one-off truthful advice. I know of a select few others in the industry that do it the way I do it. I am sure there are more than a few that I have never heard of, but I would say the majority of us are younger. So I do think there is a slight change there. Eventually when people catch wind of this there will be more public demand for it, and then some business, hopefully mine, will be there to capitalise on it and do it en masse. The problem is that for that you need people regularly asking, and the costs are high, and you need to employ people that are trustworthy. It will take time, but I think it will happen. I just hope it happens sooner rather than later. It would be awfully nice if it takes place in the next five years instead of the next 15. You will never fully get rid of the traditional model, because it is so lucrative, and some people have affairs that are more complicated than a low-cost ETF and an industry super fund. You might have $30 million. But for the overwhelming majority, it should be the best way to do it in my opinion.

One of the questions was, do you think the current model is working? I would say, it depends how you interpret the question. It is working awfully well for the people working in the industry. I just do not think it is working for clients.

Host: I am a huge advocate of educating the population rather than legislating, rather than forcing something down someone's throat, giving them the freedom to choose themselves. That is why I was so disappointed with the influencer guidelines that were released that nuked half the content creators out there. I started in 2015 and ASIC dropped the guidelines in 2022, I think. I thought there was nothing you could have learned from this explosion of content creators and bloggers and podcasts? You are all out unless you have a licence that costs tens of thousands of dollars. You cannot talk about financial products to an audience of over a thousand people. We are going to threaten you with jail time. It was a hammer to crack a nut.

Andy: I can empathise with the regulator's position, because ASIC broadly probably has to wear it. They are not as well resourced, and the idea behind it was that it is funded by the participants in the industry, so it is not a drag on government spending. I think they do a good job, and I empathise with their perspective. If you give them an inch, they will take a mile. [...] It has not stopped all these crypto people and buyers agents and quasi-whatever blatantly flouting the law anyway. They are not a financial product, so they are completely not regulated by ASIC.

Host: Is that not funny, that they are going after content creators in the ETF space and the crypto people are free game? You talk about ETFs and potentially it is jail time.

Andy: It is not ASIC's fault. They have got a mandate. It is the laws which provide their mandate and guidelines.

Host: I get it, it needs to change from the top. I am just pointing out how ridiculous it is. If the end goal is to educate people and get people quality financial advice, guess what, it is not working. And to your point, Andy, who is the industry working for? It is working for the advisors. It is not working for the people getting the advice.

Industry Funds And Passive ETFs

Host: We have been recording for a long time. You have been part of or consuming FIRE content for a few years now. What do you see as the biggest mistakes the FIRE community makes in their financial journeys?

Andy: Broadly speaking, the FIRE crowd get eight or nine out of 10 bang on. Even if I changed something, you would be taking a nine out of ten and turning it into a nine and a half out of ten. It is much less untangling errors. I always like to say there has never been so much good information out there, and so much trash information out there.

One of the biggest mistakes, and I do not think this is life changing, I just think it is an opportunity you would make more of, is that they are exclusively passively invested, and the only exception to that in my personal opinion, having done this for a long time, is superannuation. Superannuation through an industry fund is one of the only places on the planet where you can get these active, unlisted type investment options at a good price, and they are quite literally the most first-class examples of their kind. That might be investing in things like airports or ports or bridges, monopolistic assets where every time a ship docks or a plane lands, you get paid. You just cannot get these kinds of things outside of super. I do not think anyone is going to ruin themselves by ignoring it. It is more that if everything outside of super is passive, you do yourself a great service if you diversify and get something with a bit of the other stuff within your super, and only within a really high-quality offering like an industry fund. What a lot of people forget is that even if you are in the growth or balanced option of an industry fund, it is likely that a good chunk of it is passive anyway. Finance is like most things in life. It is not black and white. It is a combination of all things that gets the best result. I am a massive fan of passive investments, especially passive ETFs. I just do not think they are the best thing in your super. I think they are a great thing even in your super, but I do think there are better options.

Another thing is the perception of custodial arrangements. If I want to buy ETFs, I might be able to do it through an ETF provider that has a custodial arrangement or through a broker, and the question is, what happens if this custodian goes under, does my money disappear? There is a very big, incredibly well regarded and deservedly so financial company called Vanguard, which announced it was coming to Australia in a meaningful way and going to launch a set and forget ETF platform. In the run-up to that, you saw anecdotally all these discussions being pushed around custodial arrangements. Can anyone show me a custodian in the last 20 years in Australia that has gone under and the investors were left penniless, especially if it is a really well regulated, well-resourced custodian like JP Morgan or State Street? I do not think anyone is going to turn around in 30 years and be ruined by it, quite the opposite, but you might have made more money with less stress and had simpler tax affairs, because you get nice reports at the end of the year and you do not pay brokerage. Do not get me wrong, I reckon that Silicon Valley adage, if you are not paying for the product, you are the product, applies. Everyone should be very sceptical if a business is giving you something for free. But I have looked into how some of them do free brokerage and I have got no qualms with it at all.

What I have been seeing more and more is this notion of pooled investments in your super fund. If I am in the set and forget high growth option, they have got to make sure that if I roll out I do not leave a capital gains bill for everyone else, and a better option is to put your super into ETFs. There is one person I respect enormously on it and I know their opinions are weighted in facts, but I just do not think they have got all the information. [...] This whole notion that if you stay in an investment option with everyone else you are going to get this massive tax drag and retire with 20% less in your balance is a complete load of rubbish. We have a blog post coming out which crunches the numbers. None of this is, oh my god, you are doing the wrong thing. It is more, hey, this is something you could do slightly better.

By all means stick to your guns and stay in the exclusive passive camp, but I think the only place on earth you can get great value for money to invest in stocks and also unlisted assets is superannuation. It does not have to be all or nothing. A good chunk of these things would be passive anyway. Australian Super took their Australian equities in house a couple of years ago, I think around the end of the GFC, around 2008 or something, and that beat the market by one or two percent over that time, and because they are member owned, that almost definitely went back to their members. I think they are getting so big that they will have to passive everything at some point. But I think people should be more open to it, only through your super. That is the biggest opportunity by and large. I think the FIRE crowd does a cracking job. This stuff is not that hard. I wish it was, I would make more money, but it is quite simple.

What AI Means For Advisers

Host: What does a product like ChatGPT mean for financial advisors in the future?

Andy: That is a great question. You get people saying that ChatGPT is potentially going to be Google 2.0. Instead of googling, can someone find me a good advisor? What does it mean for us? I have asked it some questions and got trash back, like, what are the claim rates for these kinds of insurances, which I could find after 20 Googles, and it just gives you a complete shemozzle. I am not going to claim that I am a big user of it. From what I understand it will be quite good for us, because I can throw 30 PDFs or 30 studies into it and say, give me all this data. Basically time saving. I think eventually it should really replace what we do. If you look at what industries are most susceptible to the new information age, and the core of that is AI, financial planners are probably at the top, along with investment managers.

At the end of the day, this whole notion that we do not give cookie-cutter advice, we give tailored advice, well, you should, because everyone needs the same thing. They need a really good investment solution, they want to maximise the tax concessions available to them, they have got the right insurance, and they do not start the investment in the wrong structure. So it probably should be cookie cutter, and it will not be too long. Who knows, whether you overestimate or underestimate these things, before you type into an app, hey, these are all my details, what should I do, and it says, you are in a seven out of ten fund, you could stay there and you will be fine, or move into an eight or nine, or you are in a three, move to this, or you are already in a really good fund, but hey, you are 55 you should not be in high growth, or you are 25 you should be in high growth. I think it will be fantastic. At the moment it is not very good. Go to it at your own peril. The other problem is there is so much garbage information on the web and that is where it gets its info from. It might see site A claiming something bogus and then a really reputable site like Money Smart from ASIC or a big super fund, and I could not tell you if it knows to give more weighting to one over the other. We are not there at the moment.

Host: We use it in my business, we have the pro licence. They released a new feature only a couple of weeks ago called deep research. I would suggest you seriously look into this. I tried it for a very specific problem. We are buying a new car and I am going to buy through the business, and I wanted to know, is it better to lease it, finance it at X interest rate or buy it in cash? I wanted to know the opportunity cost, how much the business was growing, all the factors that weigh into the decision. I wrote this massive three-page brief that I had already sent to my accountant. I hit deep research and it came back straight away with a whole bunch of questions, like how much do you pay yourself out of the business, how many employees. Then I hit go and it thought about it for 10 minutes. Anyone that has used ChatGPT knows it is pretty instant, gives you answers within seconds. This thing thought about it for 10 minutes and the answer I got, I was blown away by how good it was. It gave me a five-page report about the three different options, what it would suggest, different scenarios, and sources so you could go to the website and verify it yourself. I gave it to my accountant and he said this is really impressive, this is beyond what I thought ChatGPT was capable of.

Andy: That might let advisors service hundreds of clients instead of three.

Andy: Yes, that is what is going to happen. The good ones will use this technology and put a human face and a human connection in front of it, but all the grunt work, getting documents together and filling out forms, a machine can do in seconds. A lot of our job is paperwork, rolling funds, submitting notices, and there is nothing that I can en masse say, prepare an application for XYZ, or do this rollover. Hopefully when that comes it will be wonderful. I think technology is a real opportunity. There will be human pain that comes from this, but in aggregate it will be something that we look back on and say, computers did this way better, way cheaper and way more accessible. You can get it at 10 o'clock on a Friday night if you want. You do not have to wait until Wednesday morning when the person has got time. You look at the most disruptable professions and it is exactly what I do, because we are glorified middlemen. I think it is fantastic.

Where To Find Andy

Host: Andy, I have exhausted all my questions. Thank you so much for your time. For anyone out there listening who is interested, where can they find you?

Andy: Our advice business is Independent Wealth Advice, iwadvice.com.au. What is probably going to be more of interest is the new business we are launching, which is called Honest Advice, or the Honest Advisor. We have a YouTube channel of that name, a podcast of that name and a website of that name, and the goal is to provide general advice en masse through workshops. Instead of paying someone thousands for an SOA, you pay a few hundred bucks to attend a workshop that goes through all of the common questions. [Editor: this has changed since recording.] As a listener to this podcast, it has been a hoot to be on it. I appreciate it. Thank you so much.

Book A Consultation

If you do not need advice, you find out for $330, not $6,600.

  • 45 minutes with the adviser himself, not a junior
  • A fixed quote on the call, if advice is warranted
  • The $330 is credited in full if you proceed

Why $330 and not free? A free first meeting is usually paid for later, through ongoing fees. I would rather you paid once for my time and owed me nothing.

Book A $330 Consultation

Pay $330 now. A consultation, not an advice session. Reschedule up to 48 hours before.